193
Dutro > Writing Wounded
English Education , January 2011
Elizabeth Dutro
I
n his book, A Scream Goes through the House, literary scholar Arnold Wein-
stein writes that he once began the first session of his university literature
course by asking his students, “How many of you are hurting now?” His
point is that emotions are part and parcel of literature study and of class-
room life and too often bracketed from our notions of what constitutes an
education or a curriculum. He also writes that he could have asked about
other emotions—“How many of you are delighted?” (2003, p. xxii)—and the
students would be equally surprised by the question. Equally surprised? Prob-
ably. But equally affected? I don’t think so. I think Weinstein asked about
hurt because he intuits that pain, loss, trauma—whatever term we might
attach to it—is the most resonant emotion to tap for his goals of supporting
students’ connections to the visceral aspects of literary engagement. In my
university teaching and through my research with students in high-poverty
schools, I have come to believe that such an explicit acknowledgment of
the hard stuff of life is important in classrooms. I must believe it or I would
not choose to share, in the first session of my writing classes, this draft of an
autobiographical essay:
When the subject of siblings arises at dinner parties, I consider my re-
sponses carefully. If I decide to be honest, I know that I will single-handedly
The scream that goes through the house is the heartbeat that makes audible, at last,
who we are, how resonant we are, how connected we are.
—Weinstein, 2003, p. xii
Writing Wounded: Trauma, Testimony,
and Critical Witness in Literacy
Classrooms
Extending the Conversation
Copyright © 2011 by the National Council of Teachers of English. All rights reserved.