Children’s and parents’ thoughts and feelings about
adoption, birth culture identity and discrimination in
families with internationally adopted children
Marta Reinoso*, Femmie Juffer† and Wendy Tieman†
*Department of Personality, Faculty of Psychology, University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain, and †Centre for Child &
Family Studies, Leiden University, Leiden, the Netherlands
ABSTRACT
We examined the perceptions of adoption and related issues in 68
families with internationally adopted children in Spain (48 transracial
and 20 same-race adoptions). The adopted children, between the ages
of 8 and 12 years, and their parents answered questions about the
children’s thoughts and feelings about adoption. Descriptive data and
scores on four scales – family, adoption, birth culture identity and
discrimination – were obtained. Compared with same-race adoptees,
transracial adoptees scored significantly higher on birth culture iden-
tity and perceived discrimination. High levels of convergence
between the children’s and parents’ viewpoints on the experiences of
adoption and related issues were found. Nevertheless, the adopted
children scored higher than their parents on birth culture identity,
suggesting that at this age adoptive parents may underestimate their
children’s connection to their cultural origins. In contrast, the same-
race adoptees scored significantly lower on perceived discrimination
than their mothers. We conclude that at this age adoptive parents
should acknowledge their adopted child’s daily-life experiences
regarding cultural identity with the birth country and discrimination.
Correspondence:
Marta Reinoso,
Department of Personality,
Faculty of Psychology,
University of Barcelona,
Passeig de la Vall d’Hebron 171,
Barcelona 08035,
Spain
E-mail: mreinoso@ub.edu
Keywords: being adopted, birth
culture identity, discrimination,
international adoption, middle
childhood, race/ethnicity
Accepted for publication: January
2012
INTRODUCTION
While psychological outcomes of internationally
adopted children have received a great deal of atten-
tion (for a review, see Palacios & Brodzinsky 2010),
relatively few studies have examined their experiences
related to their adoptive status. How do adoptees
come to terms with being adopted and looking differ-
ent? In this study, we examined children’s and
parents’ thoughts and feelings about adoption and
related issues. The children, aged 8–12 years, were all
internationally adopted to Spain.
As Brodzinsky et al. (1992, p. 7) stated, ‘Being
adopted can be something that colours a person’s
relationship with their adoptive parents, their emerg-
ing sense of self, and the intimate relationships they
forge for the rest of their life’. The issue of being
adopted is one that will be returned to, consciously
and unconsciously, at various points in an adoptee’s
development. In middle childhood, adopted chil-
dren’s understanding and appreciation of the implica-
tions of adoption grow at a profound rate. Children
enter what Piaget (1954) called the period of concrete
operations, which enables them to understand the
world in a logical manner. This is when adopted chil-
dren begin to appreciate the uniqueness of this family
status and to consider the meaning of being adopted
(Brodzinsky et al. 1984, 1992). They start to recognize
that adoption implies not just building a family (their
adoptive family) but also losing a family (their birth
Author’s note: Marta Reinoso was supported by the Comis-
sionat per a Universitats i Recerca del DIUE de la Generali-
tat de Catalunya and the European Social Funds. Femmie
Juffer was supported by Wereldkinderen.
doi:10.1111/j.1365-2206.2012.00841.x
264 Child and Family Social Work 2013, 18, pp 264–274 © 2012 John Wiley & Sons Ltd