330 Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 88 (1988) 330-336
Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Amsterdam - Printed in The Netherlands
[6]
Nuclide analyses of rare earth elements of the Oklo uranium ore samples:
a new method to estimate the neutron fluence
Hiroshi Hidaka * and Akimasa Masuda
Department of Chemistry, University of Tokyo, Tokyo 113 (Japan)
Received February 23, 1987; revised version received January 19, 1988
Isotopic ratios and abundances of all REE in two Oklo ore samples have been measured. We have succeeded in
developing a new method to estimate the neutron fluence, the conversion factor of uranium and the average neutron
energy (or temperature) based on Gd and U isotopic ratios. This new calculation is found to be useful in evaluating
those parameters for the natural nuclear reactors at Oklo. Comparison is made between the neutron fluence values
evaluated by our new method employing Gd isotopes and a previous one [11] employing Sm and Nd isotopes. The
relative agreement becomes better with the increase of fluence. A relationship between the abundances of fissiongenic
nuclides of La, Ce, Nd, Sm, and Gd and their mass numbers is also presented.
1. Introduction
After the discovery of the natural reactor at
Oklo, many studies have been performed. Most of
them have been published in reports issued by
IAEA [1,2]. Since 235U is consumed in the nuclear
fission reaction induced by the thermal neutron,
235U is depleted relative to 238U. (In an unusual
case, however, 235U can be enriched [3].) And for
many other elements, isotopic anomalies are found
due to the nuclear reactions of fission and neutron
capture [4-9].
Production rates for many nuclides of rare earth
elements (REE) in the natural reactor should be
relatively large because of their high fission prod-
uct yields and large cross sections for neutron
capture. As REE are non-volatile and less soluble
elements, retentions of them in the reactor must
have been considerably good, even if not perfect
in the reactor. Therefore, the effect of fission can
be particularly remarkable for REE. We investi-
gated both isotopic abundance ratios and con-
centrations, of REE and U for two Oklo samples.
The first aim of our study was to evaluate the
working parameters of the Oklo reactor by a new
* Now at Toshiba Research and Development Center,
Kanagawa 210, Japan.
0012-821X/88/$03.50 © 1988 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V.
calculation system, employing isotopic composi-
tion of Gd. The second was to examine the behav-
iors of REE. It is hoped that the knowledge about
the behaviors of fission products can be of much
help for the studies concerning the disposal of
radioactive waste. In this paper, however, empha-
sis is placed on the first point.
This is the first research to investigate the
abundances of all of stable nuclides for all REE in
the same samples. Besides, we have measured the
isotopic compositions of all of "ordinary" REE by
ourselves, employing the commercially available
reagents. Loubet and All6gre carried out a similar
examination [10], but they did not present the
data on 138Ce, 144Smi 152Gd, 154Gd, 156Dy, 158Dy,
16°Dy, 162Er, 164Er, tV°Er and 168yb. Holliger and
Devillers [11] presented the complete isotopic
composition data for four Oklo samples, but there
are no observations for La and Ce. Major concern
of these researchers was to estimate the average
equilibrium temperature of the neutrons at the
time of the nuclear reactions, based on 176Lu/
175Lu ratio.
2. Experimental procedures
2.1. Samples
Two Oklo samples were used in this work. For
convenience, we call them A and B. Sample A is