Abstract-- An efficient method to address the multi-stage
planning of open loop structured mv distribution networks under
uncertainty, taking into account distributed generation connected
to distribution system, has been proposed. The fuzzy model can
cope with important features implicit in planning studies such as
time-phased representation, consideration of conflicting
objectives and uncertainty in loads, distributed generation and
economic data. Using two evolutionary algorithms simultaneous
optimization of costs and the reliability is achieved. Thus, in
addition to optimal radial layout along several stages in time, the
algorithm can determine the optimal locations of reserve feeders
that achieve the best network reliability with the lowest
expansion and operational costs. The model and evolutionary
algorithms have been applied intensively to real life power
distribution systems showing its potential applicability to
significantly larger systems than those frequently found in
literature about dynamic distribution networks planning. Results
have illustrated the significant influence of the uncertainties in
the optimal distribution network planning mainly in terms of
topology and supply capacity of the resulting optimal distribution
system.
Index Terms--primary distribution network, planning, open
loop network, evolutionary algorithm, dynamic model,
uncertainty, robustness, fuzzy sets
I. INTRODUCTION
ANY mathematical models have been proposed in the
past for electrical distribution network planning. Most
of those neglect that one is dealing with a dynamic multi-
temporal problem under uncertainty. On the other hand,
considering the evolution in power demand through time and
consequent topological changes in the networks, dynamic
planning have never been a definite success, when applied to
real sized networks. Large network problems have been
addressed for linearized objective functions. Branch and
bound applications can be found in [1,2], mixed-integer
programming in [3] together with Bender’s decomposition [4]
and with branch exchange [5]. Dynamic programming
approaches have been taken in [6,8]. More recently,
evolutionary computation techniques have also been proposed
[7,8,9,10]. In [7] evolutionary algorithm with integer
codification has been proposed giving an optimal solution for
a fixed set of data and a single time period only. [8,9,10] are
string genotype approaches to small-size network problems.
For large networks the combinatorial nature of decision
M. Skok, D. Skrlec and S. Krajcar are with the Department of Power
Systems, University of Zagreb, Faculty of Electrical Engineering and
Computing, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia (e-mail: Minea.Skok@fer.hr).
making turns such genetic algorithms (GAs) into
computationally expensive approaches. Due to the use of
standard (binary) solution encoding and standard genetic
operators the following problems have been observed:
topological unfeasibility (connectivity, radiality) [8,9],
low heritability (a significant number of offsprings
generated by the crossover operator hardly have
substructures of their parents),
suitable building of additional lines (reserve feeders’
segments used in contingency conditions to improve
reliability of supply) is not included, or if it is, then
methods have been classified as single-stage (static).
To our knowledge, only four researchers have devised
methods suitable for the problem of open loop distribution
system planning, and neither of these is multistage (dynamic)
or considers the intrinsic uncertainties of data [11,12,13,14].
This paper presents a suitable fuzzy model to deal with the
uncertainties from future demand, distributed generation and
economic data in order to solve long term large scale multi-
stage open loop mv distribution network planning problem
under uncertainty. A method based on two interrelated
evolutionary algorithms is used to generate sets of dynamic
distribution network solutions. Furthermore, besides radial
operational topology, optimal reserve cables that achieve the
best network reliability with the lowest economical costs for
multi-stage optimal designs are determined. The proposed
method was tested with real size systems achieving optimal
plans in reasonable CPU times compared with the dimensions
of such systems.
II. OPTIMIZATION TECNIQUE
A. General outline (two evolutionary algorithms)
Along several stages in time the proposed optimization
technique searches for the set of decisions (associated with
investment costs - new lines, new substations, reinforcement
of an existing system, operation costs – maintenance, demand
and energy costs - and reliability – expected energy not
supplied) that “optimize” the global cost of system
development. The development of the system is simulated by
two interrelated evolutionary algorithms that are used to
generate sets of dynamic distribution network solutions
(Fig.1). The master (main) evolutionary algorithm is aimed at
optimizing the open loop network layout in the last year of the
study period (e.g. 5-20 years ahead) and the slave EA is used
in each iteration of the master EA to produce an optimized
plan for the final year, identifying schedule (as a set of yearly
M. Skok, Member, IEEE, S. Krajcar, Member, IEEE , and D. Skrlec, Member, IEEE
Dynamic Planning of Medium Voltage Open-
Loop Distribution Networks under Uncertainty
M
551 1-59975-028-7/05/$20.00 © 2005 ISAP.