The Role of Emotional Congruence in Human-Robot
Interaction
Karoline Malchus
Applied Informatics
Bielefeld, Germany
karoline.malchus@uni-bielefeld.de
Prisca Stenneken
Clinical Linguistics
Bielefeld, Germany
prisca.stenneken@uni-bielefeld.de
Petra Jaecks
Clinical Linguistics
Bielefeld, Germany
petra.jaecks@uni-bielefeld.de
Carolin Meyer
Clinical Linguistics
Bielefeld, Germany
and
Speech and Language Therapy
Hamburg, Germany
carolin.meyer@hs-fresenius.de
Oliver Damm
Applied Informatics
Bielefeld, Germany
odamm@techfak.uni-bielefeld.de
Britta Wrede
Applied Informatics
Bielefeld, Germany
bwrede@techfak.uni-bielefeld.de
Abstract— The communication of emotion is a crucial part of
daily life interaction. Therefore, we carried out a study to
research which role emotional congruence plays in human-
human and human-robot interaction. In our results there is no
effect of emotional incongruence between verbal content and
facial expression of human as well as robotic stimuli on the
cognitive performance in a story comprehension task. But more
importantly, results indicate, that participants’ performance in a
memorizing task is significantly better if the robot tells the story.
Possible explanations will be discussed.
IndexTerms— Emotional Congruence, Emotional Conflict,
Human-Robot Interaction, Story Comprehension Task
I. INTRODUCTION
Social Communication between interlocutors is one of the
most important, but also most complex aspects in daily life. It
involves many processes to perceive, transmit and understand
the communicated information. One of these processes deals
with emotional information. These emotions can be expressed
multi-modally, e.g. through face, voice or semantic meaning.
To build robots, which can act in real life, we have to think
about the influence of emotions in human-robot interactions.
Therefore, it is important to explore the similarities and
differences between emotional human-human and human-
robot interactions.
During an interaction, emotions can play different roles and
can influence for example the perception of our interaction
partners, the perception of the communicated information or
our cognitive processes [3]. Ruz and Tudela [8] for example
report, that emotions displayed by another person affect our
decision-making in social contexts. Also for human-robot
interactions, there are many studies about the necessity of
emotion perception and production to diversify the interaction
and make it more natural and easy [7].
But what happens, if the communicated information is
emotionally incongruent? Arai et al. [1] demonstrated with
their study, that already 8-10 month old infants have a neural
basis for the detection of emotional conflicts or incongruence
of voice tone and facial expressions. According to their results
and other studies (e.g. [5]), we assume that emotions are not
only a natural part of communication but also that there is an
important influence of congruency.
With our study, we want to investigate the interplay of
emotional and cognitive aspects in human-robot compared to
human-human interaction. We focus on the influence of
emotionally conflicting robotic and human stimuli on
cognitive aspects like memory and inference processes in a
story comprehension task. Participants had to combine
incoming linguistic information, their world knowledge and
nonverbal communicative cues into a more and more complex
discourse and situation model. A change or a development of
the situation model occurs, when new information fail to
overlap in one or more features for example like causality or
intentionality [6].
II. METHOD
A. Participants
One hundred-four students from Bielefeld University (Mean
Age: 28,3; SD: 9,51; 65 women) participated in this study for
course credits or 15 € fee. All participants were German native
speakers and had normal or corrected-to-normal vision and
hearing. Participants were screened via self-report about
previous or actual neurological and psychiatric diseases.
B. Material
Narratives
Stimuli consisted of two adapted video-screened versions of
the story “Herbstgespräche im Blumenhimmel [Autumn talks
in flowers’ heaven]”[2]. In one condition, a professional male
978-1-4673-3101-2/13/$31.00 © 2013 IEEE 191 HRI 2013 Proceedings