Chapter 4
Waiting to Speak: A Phenomenological
Perspective on Our Silence Around Dying
Kirsten Jacobson
Abstract Drawing from existential and empirical accounts, I consider the pain that
relates to our recognition of our own mortality, especially focusing on our con-
temporary silence around mortality and our tendencies to generalize and medicalize
death. Examining Heidegger ’s distinction between “ontic” structures concealing
death and the “ontological” significance underlying this concealing, I argue that,
though this silence arises from our way of being-in-the-world, there are reasons for
challenging institutional and social structures pushing us to cover over death and
the existential suffering associated with it. I argue it is incumbent upon the medical
community specifically, and ultimately all of us, to respond to silence surrounding
dying by cultivating practices of listening, thereby opening possibilities for a more
authentic relationship to our dying.
Keywords Martin Heidegger
Á
Being-towards-death
Á
Existential health
Á
Anxiety
Á
Dying
Á
Medicalization
In this chapter, I use existential authors—Martin Heidegger, Rainer Maria Rilke, and
J.H. van den Berg—as well as empirical discussions from medical practitioners and
patients to consider the pain that relates to our recognition of our own mortality,
focusing especially on ways in which contemporary silence around our mortality as
well as our related tendencies to generalize and medicalize death often work toward
covering over this pain. Drawing especially on Heidegger, and his distinction between
the “ontic” or worldly structures that conceal the nature of our death and the “onto-
logical” or existential significance underlying this concealing, I ultimately argue that,
though this silence arises from the existential depths of our way of being-in-the-world,
there are nonetheless reasons for addressing this by challenging the worldly institu-
tional and social structures that push us toward this covering over of the experience of
dying. I argue it is incumbent upon the medical community specifically, and all of us
more broadly, to respond to this silence around dying by cultivating practices of
listening, and thereby to open up possibilities for a more authentic relationship to our
K. Jacobson (&)
University of Maine, Orono, USA
e-mail: kirsten.jacobson@maine.edu
© Springer India 2016
S.K. George and P.G. Jung (eds.), Cultural Ontology
of the Self in Pain, DOI 10.1007/978-81-322-2601-7_4
75
kirsten.jacobson@maine.edu