The Effects of Pre-task Planning on the Writing
Fluency of Iranian EFL Learners
Reza Biria
Department of English, Khorasgan (Isfahan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran
Zahra Karimi
Department of English, Khorasgan (Isfahan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran
Abstract—According to Nunan (2004), Task-Based Language Teaching is an approach to the use of tasks as
fundamental units of planning and language instruction in language teaching. The present study aimed to
investigate the impact of pre-task planning on the fluency of the argumentative essays written by Iranian male
and female EFL learners with an intermediate proficiency level. For this purpose, an IELTS Writing Task was
administered to a population of 100 EFL learners studying at an English institute in Isfahan. Based on their
scores, a sample of 50 intermediate level students were selected and randomly divided into two homogenous
groups, 25 each. These samples served as control and experimental groups respectively. The role of gender
differences was also investigated in this study. Accordingly, the learners in control group were taught by a
structure-based traditional approach while the learners in experimental group were taught by a task-based
approach. In order to compare the collected data of the two groups, several t tests were utilized. The obtained
results of the written essays by the male students revealed that pre-task planning improved fluency. On the
other hand, the comparison of the essays written by the females in both group revealed that they produced
more fluent texts.
Index Terms— task, task-based language teaching, argumentative essays, fluency
I. INTRODUCTION
Communicating with people from other countries with different cultures, attitudes, and social backgrounds through
foreign languages has always been of a great concern to human. The dominant method in language teaching was
Grammar Translation Method up to the 1940s. The focus of the method was on grammar and translation from L2 to L1
and vice versa. Because the Grammar Translation Method emphasizes reading rather than the ability to communicate in
a language there was a reaction to it. Then the changes in communicative needs and the developments in psychology
and linguistics led to the rapid emergence of new methods and approaches, with a new look at different aspects of
teaching and learning foreign languages. This shift of focus introduced the Communicative Language Teaching (CLT)
to the teaching profession.
Developing “communicative competence” in learners and paying attention to all four skills were the main goals of
language teaching in Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) (Richard & Rodgers, 2001; Brown, 2007). In CLT, the
primary attention paid to meaning rather than the formal features of language give rise to learning to communicate the
intended meaning. Therefore, CLT put a considerable emphasis on fluency and claimed that accuracy can be improved
by improving fluency. Based on Brown (2007, p. 241) “CLT is best understood as an approach not a method” and many
other new methods have been derived from it. Task Based Language Teaching (TBLT) is a “logical development of
CLT” (Richard & Rodgers, 2001; p. 233). Tasks are the basic and fundamental units of planning and instruction in
TBLT (Ellis, 2000, 2003; Littlewood, 2004).
Many scholars have used task in their curricula and methodologies and they have long been part of the ELT.
However, Task-based language teaching (TBLT) offers a totally different rational for the utilization of tasks in language
teaching. In addition, TBLT presents some essential criteria for devising, choosing and sequencing tasks in the
classroom instruction for the teachers. Here tasks are utilized as the main output units in instruction, practice and even
in evaluation. Moreover, task-based instruction has very stronger bedrock in theory and research such as cognitive
approach to language teaching and the concept of psychological reality in psycholinguistic theories.
Concerning the ability to write in a foreign language, the bulk of research indicates that it is gaining increasing
importance. Accordingly, the instruction in writing is assuming a more fundamental role. In the past, writing skill was
not considered as an important skill due to ambiguous nature of writing and it was not investigated by the researchers.
Thus the dominant approach in teaching writing was the “product approach” which focuses on the end product of
writing and put the emphasis on writing aspects like grammar, vocabulary, punctuation and spelling. According to
Badger and White 2000, “In product based approaches writing concerned with the structure knowledge of language, and
writing development the result of the group’s imitation, in the text form provided by the researcher ” (p. 154).
ISSN 1798-4769
Journal of Language Teaching and Research, Vol. 6, No. 2, pp. 357-365, March 2015
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17507/jltr.0602.16
© 2015 ACADEMY PUBLICATION