The transmission and stability of cultural life scripts: a cross-cultural study
Steve M. J. Janssen
a,b
and Shamsul Haque
c
a
School of Psychology, University of Nottingham – Malaysia Campus, Semenyih, Malaysia;
b
School of Psychology, Flinders University,
Adelaide, Australia;
c
Department of Psychology, Jeffrey Cheah School of Medicine and Health Sciences, Monash University – Malaysia,
Bandar Sunway, Malaysia
ABSTRACT
Cultural life scripts are shared knowledge about the timing of important life events. In the
present study, we examined whether cultural life scripts are transmitted through traditions
and whether there are additional ways through which they can be attained by asking
Australian and Malaysian participants which information sources they had used to generate
the life script of their culture. Participants hardly reported that they had used cultural and
religious traditions. They more often reported that they had used their own experiences and
experiences of relatives and friends. They also reported the use of comments of relatives and
friends and the use of newspapers, books, movies and television programmes. Furthermore,
we examined the stability of life scripts and similarities and differences across cultures. We
found that life scripts are stable cognitive structures and that there are, besides cross-cultural
differences in the content, small cross-cultural differences in the valence and distribution of
life script events, with the Australian life script containing more positive events and more
events expected to occur before the age of 16.
ARTICLE HISTORY
Received 26 September 2016
Accepted 21 May 2017
KEYWORDS
Autobiographical memory;
cultural life script; identity;
social learning theory;
vicarious memories
Cultural life scripts are semantic knowledge about the
timing for important life events likely to occur in an ideal-
ised life course (Berntsen & Rubin, 2002, 2004). It has been
argued that this knowledge is used when people tell their
life story (Berntsen & Bohn, 2010; Bohn, 2010). Although 10
properties have been proposed, we will examine the prop-
erty that suggests that cultural life scripts are transmitted
through traditions. Although there have been studies
which have shown that life scripts are formed throughout
childhood (Bohn & Berntsen, 2008; Habermas, 2007), the
present study is the first one – as far as we know – that
has examined the transmission of life scripts. Besides
examining the role of traditions, we will also explore if
there are additional ways through which people can
learn about the life script of their culture and examine
the stability of life scripts and similarities and differences
in life scripts across two cultures (i.e., Australia and
Malaysia).
Cultural life scripts
Life scripts, which combine the concept of story scripts
(Schank & Abelson, 1977) with that of age norms (Neugar-
ten, Moore, & Lowe, 1965), are defined as culturally shared
representations of the order and timing of transitional
events in a prototypical life course (Berntsen & Rubin,
2004). Cultural life scripts do not represent a list of remem-
bered experiences but events expected to occur in an
idealised life course. Life scripts exist as shared cognitive
structures influencing the retrieval of positive over nega-
tive events and of events from early adulthood over
those from other lifetime periods.
Berntsen and Rubin (2004) proposed 10 properties of
life scripts, six of which were derived from Schank and
Abelson (1977), describing them as: (1) semantic knowl-
edge about expectations regarding; (2) a series of tem-
porally ordered life events; (3) defined in terms of their
time slots; (4) forming a hierarchical arrangement, with
transitional events forming a higher order (scene), in
which a series of subordinate actions or episodes are
nested; (5) used to process life stories and (6) comprising
culturally important transitional events with culturally sanc-
tioned timing. The remaining four properties were pro-
posed by Berntsen and Rubin (2004): (7) life scripts do
not represent an average but an idealised life, from
which many common and some important life events are
omitted; (8) life scripts are distorted from actual lives to
favour positive events and (9) events expected to occur
in early adulthood; (10) and, because life scripts represent
a normative life course, they are not based on personally
experienced events but transmitted through traditions.
Two methods have been used to examine life scripts (cf.,
Janssen & Haque, 2015). The first method requires partici-
pants to estimate at what age highly emotional events,
such as the happiest, saddest, most loving, most fearful,
most important and most traumatic event, might occur in
© 2017 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
CONTACT Steve M. J. Janssen steve.janssen@nottingham.edu.my School of Psychology, University of Nottingham – Malaysia Campus, B1B21, Jalan
Broga, 43500 Semenyih, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia
MEMORY, 2017
https://doi.org/10.1080/09658211.2017.1335327