Journal of Vegetation Science && (2017)
Biotic homogenization in an increasingly urbanized
temperate grassland ecosystem
Ben J. Zeeman, Mark J. McDonnell, Dave Kendal & John W. Morgan
Keywords
Alien species; Biotic differentiation;
Disturbance; Extinction; Habitat fragmentation;
Immigration; Invasion; Plant functional traits;
Vegetation dynamics
Nomenclature
The International Plant Names Index:
http://ipni.org/
Received 15 March 2016
Accepted 14 December 2016
Co-ordinating Editor: Sebastian Schmidtlein
Zeeman, B.J. (corresponding author,
BZeeman@ltu.edu.au)
1
,
McDonnell, M.J. (markmc@unimelb.edu.au)
2
,
Kendal, D. (dkendal@unimelb.edu.au)
2,3
,
Morgan, J.W. (J.Morgan@latrobe.edu.au)
1
1
Department of Ecology, Environment and
Evolution, La Trobe University, Bundoora,
Vic. 3086, Australia;
2
School of BioSciences, The University of
Melbourne, Burnley, Vic. 3010, Australia;
3
School of Ecosystem and Forest Sciences, The
University of Melbourne, Burnley, Vic. 3121,
Australia
Abstract
Question: How does urbanization and associated declines in fire frequency alter
the floristic composition of native temperate grasslands? Does it lead to: (1) bio-
tic homogenization, i.e. compositional similarity between remnants increases;
(2) biotic differentiation, whereby similarity between remnants declines, or; (3)
clustered differentiation, where similarity between remnants remains
unchanged, but composition shifts from the historical state?
Location: Victoria, Australia.
Methods: Using site-level surveys, we examined changes in the floristic similar-
ity of 29 urban grasslands from 1992 to 2013 and compared these changes to
those of 63 rural grasslands from 1989 to 2014. Community-level changes in the
representation of key functional traits were also examined in urban grasslands,
with traits advantaged following disturbance regime change and urban
fragmentation predicted to increase in frequency.
Results: Our results supported the biotic homogenization hypothesis in urban
grasslands. Compositional similarity between grasslands increased principally
because of an increase in commonly shared non-native species, with change in
native composition comparatively minor. However, no evidence of biotic
homogenization was found in rural grasslands, with no significant change in
overall composition identified. The most urbanized sites had the highest number
of non-native species in both the current and historical data sets, yet non-native
composition over the past two decades changed the most in sites on the urban
fringe, becoming more similar to sites closer to the urban core. As expected, fol-
lowing declines in fire frequency and increased urbanization, the overall compo-
sition of urban grasslands shifted to taller plant species, while native species
capable of vegetative reproduction and exotic species with an annual life span
increased in frequency.
Conclusion: Urbanization was an important driver of biodiversity change in the
investigated system, with increasing competition intensity in response to distur-
bance regime change a likely cause of biotic homogenization. Our results demon-
strate that non-native species are a key driver of biotic homogenization,
emphasizing the importance of managing non-native immigration and maintain-
ing historical disturbance processes once native ecosystems become urbanized.
Introduction
Human activities are transforming native ecosystems
across the globe (Vitousek et al. 1997; Steffen et al.
2007). Urbanization is a particularly threatening pro-
cess, reducing the area of native vegetation and isolat-
ing remnant patches through fragmentation (McDonald
et al. 2008; Secretariat of the Convention on Biological
Diversity 2012). Once bound within the urban matrix,
resource supply between communities is disrupted and
species dispersal is constrained (Ricketts 2001; Williams
et al. 2006; Ibanez et al. 2014). Additionally, historic
disturbance regimes are altered (Harrison & Bruna
1999), and environmental conditions are modified
(Grimm et al. 2008), shifting the nature of species
interactions, and creating novel ecosystems through
1
Journal of Vegetation Science
Doi: 10.1111/jvs.12507 © 2017 International Association for Vegetation Science