Field Dependence of Mobilities for Gas-Phase-Protonated Monomers and Proton-Bound
Dimers of Ketones by Planar Field Asymmetric Waveform Ion Mobility Spectrometer
(PFAIMS)
E. Krylov, E. G. Nazarov, R. A. Miller,
²
B. Tadjikov, and G. A. Eiceman*
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, New Mexico State UniVersity, Las Cruces, New Mexico 88003, and
SIONEX Corporation, Wellesley Hills, Massachusetts 02481
ReceiVed: January 8, 2002; In Final Form: March 19, 2002
The dependence of the mobilities of gas-phase ions on electric fields from 0 to 90 Td at ambient pressure
was determined for protonated monomers [(MH
+
(H
2
O)
n
] and proton bound dimers [M
2
H
+
(H
2
O)
n
] for a
homologous series of normal ketones, from acetone to decanone (M ) C
3
H
6
O to C
10
H
20
O). This dependence
was measured as the normalized function of mobility R(E/N) using a planar field asymmetric waveform ion
mobility spectrometer (PFAIMS) and the ions were mass-identified using a PFAIMS drift tube coupled to a
tandem mass spectrometer. Methods are described to obtain R(E/N) from the measurements of compensation
voltage versus amplitude of an asymmetric waveform of any shape. Slopes of R for MH
+
versus E/N were
monotonic from 0 to 90 Td for acetone, butanone, and pentanone. Plots for ketones from hexanone to octanone
exhibited plateaus at high fields. Nonanone and decanone showed plots with an inversion of slope above 70
Td. Proton bound dimers for ketones with carbon numbers greater than five exhibited slopes for R versus
E/N, which decreased continuously with increasing E/N. These findings are the first alpha values for ions
from a homologous series under atmosphere pressure and are preliminary to explanations of R(E/N) with ion
structure.
Introduction
The motion of gas-phase ions in electric fields at pressures
greater than 1 Torr has been explored for over a century
1-3
and
velocities of ion swarms in controlled atmospheres of drift tubes
have been used since the 1960s to model interactions between
ions and molecules.
4-7
In recent years, these principles have
been developed in mobility spectrometers for the detection of
chemical warfare agents and explosives.
8
In general, ion motion
is measured as velocity (V
d
, cm/s) in uniform gradients of electric
fields (E, V/cm) low enough so that velocity is proportional to
the electric field through a constant, the coefficient of mobility
(i.e., K )V
d
/E, cm
2
/Vs). One relationship between the mobility
coefficient, ion structure, and the gas atmosphere is eq 1:
5
where the terms are e, elementary charge; N, drift gas density;
μ, reduced ion/neutral mass; T
eff
, effective temperature of the
ion; and Ω, collisional cross section.
The mobility coefficient is characteristic of the structure of
an ion and the ion-molecule interactions in a gas; also, K is
influenced by collision frequency and energy obtained from
the field by ions between collisions. The average energy
acquired from the electric field is determined by E/N and is
considered negligible when E/N is small since any energy
gained by the ion from the field is dissipated at high pres-
sures by collisions with the supporting gas. Under such
conditions, K is a constant and independent of E/N. However,
the mobility coefficient becomes dependent on electric field with
increasing values of E/N as shown in eq 2:
5,7,9
where terms are K(0), the mobility coefficient under low field
conditions and R
2
, R
4
, ..., R
2n
, specific coefficients of even
powers of the electric field; E/N is in units of Td (under normal
conditions 1 Td corresponds to 268.67 V/cm since E ) N
0
10
-17
,
where N
0
is Loschmidt’s constant). The mobility coefficient
should be expressed as an even power series in E/N due to
symmetry considerations (i.e., the absolute value for ion velocity
is independent of electric field direction). When experimental
conditions are constant, unique patterns for K versus E/N exist
for different ions due to characteristic values of R
2n
.A
simplification of eq 2 has been described
10
where an alpha
function is used for the electric field dependence of the
coefficient of mobility per eq 3:
where R(E/N) )R
2
(E/N)
2
+R
4
(E/N)
4
+ .... This formula is a
function showing the nonlinear electric field dependence of
mobility for specific ions.
Extensive experimental findings exist for the nonlinear
dependence of the mobility coefficient on electric field though
studies were restricted to simple ions or ions containing only a
few atoms. Results available in the Atomic Data of Nuclear
Data Tables show that K
o
is a nonlinear function with increasing
E/N at subambient pressures.
11-14
Comparable findings at
ambient pressure (high neutral gas density), where ion-neutral
processes exert a dominant role in forming mobility spectra,
are not generally available. Only a few studies for the measure-
ment of K(E/N) at ambient pressure have been made owing to
²
SIONEX Corporation.
K )
3e
16N
2π
μkT
eff
1
Ω
1.1
(T
eff
)
(1)
K(E/N) ) K(0)[1 +R
2
(E/N)
2
+R
4
(E/N)
4
+ ...] (2)
K(E/N) ) K(0)[1 +R(E/N)] (3)
5437 J. Phys. Chem. A 2002, 106, 5437-5444
10.1021/jp020009i CCC: $22.00 © 2002 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 05/14/2002