Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Materials & Design
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/matdes
Analytical modeling of grinding-induced subsurface damage in
monocrystalline silicon
Hao Nan Li
⁎
, Tian Biao Yu, Li Da Zhu, Wan Shan Wang
School of Mechanical Engineering and Automation, Northeastern University, Shenyang Zip 110819, PR China
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Monocrystalline silicon
Grinding
Subsurface damage
ABSTRACT
Monocrystalline silicon is a predominant type of semiconductors. However, subsurface damage (SSD) of silicon
has been widely reported during the mechanical grinding process. Although relevant efforts have been reported,
most theoretical studies only qualitatively explained the SSD formation mechanism rather than quantitatively
evaluate SSD values, while most experimental measurement techniques unavoidably damaged (even destroyed)
the ground surfaces and therefore could only be ultilised ex-situ. To fill this gap, this paper suggests an analytical
model of grinding-induced SSD in silicon, where the explicit relationship between SSD and the ground surface
roughness Rz is analytically established considering the (i) ductile-regime effect, (ii) crystallographic orientation
effect, and (iii) material property degradation due to high grinding temperature. Based on the model, grinding-
induced SSD could be nondestructively, quickly and conveniently evaluated, in-situ or ex-situ, by measuring Rz
values based on a handheld profilometer. Grinding trials indicated the model could accurately evaluate SSD
depths along both the <100> and <110> crystallographic orientations in both dry and wet silicon grinding
processes. Further discussion on how the model could guide and monitor the industrial silicon grinding is also
presented. The proposed model therefore is anticipated to be meaningful to facilitate design, manufacture, and
applications of monocrystalline silicon.
1. Introduction
Monocrystalline silicon is a predominant type of semiconductor
materials, and is considered as the building block of many electronic
devices [1,2], such as large-scale integrated circuits (IC), high-effi-
ciency solar cells, microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) and high-
performance semiconductor equipment. During industrial manufactur-
ing of silicon, grinding is commonly utilised as the last “rough”
machining process prior to high-precision lapping because grinding
can achieve high material removal rates with relatively low cost [3,4].
However, substantial experimental observations [5–7] indicated that
grinding process easily led to significant subsurface damage (SSD)
including micro-cracks, dislocation, and stacking faults, even under a
smooth ground surface. This SSD was reported to be not only harmful to
mechanical properties and service life of silicon products, but also
influential to functional performances of semiconductors or electronic
components [8]. To this end, a multitude of efforts focusing on the
understanding or characterisation of the grinding-induced SSD in
monocrystalline silicon have been made.
In the early-stage research, the formation mechanism of SSD has
been explored by performing indentation tests or scratch trials. Cheong
and Zhang [9] observed the nano-indentation events and found that the
SSD of silicon was formed accompanying with the phase transforma-
tion, where the diamond cubic silicon (Si-I) was transformed into the
metallic state (Si-II). Zarudi et al. [10] further improved Cheong and
Zhang's study [9] by performing the cyclic indentation tests so as to
imitate the similar cyclic loads of the cutter-specimen interaction in
machining processes. Another two new crystalline phases including the
body centered-cubic silicon (Si-III) and the rhombohedral silicon (Si-
XII) were found several microns beneath the surface, and therefore
these two phases were believed related with SSD in silicon machining.
Besides, Zarudi et al. [11] assumed the temperature rise induced by the
indenter-workpiece friction might also contribute to the SSD formation,
but the cryogenic scratching test of silicon specimens showed the very
limited effect of the low temperature on the reduction of SSD depths.
Instead of using a geometrically well-defined indenter, the second-
stage research started to perform real machining trials. Yan et al. [12]
conducted straightforward diamond machining experiments on silicon
specimens by using cutting tools with different rake angles, and the
results indicated that in grinding, where the abrasive negative rake
angle was usually large (around −60°), the SSD depths were mono-
tonously increased with the increasing depths of cut. Therefore a good
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2017.05.068
Received 23 December 2016; Received in revised form 22 May 2017; Accepted 24 May 2017
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: lhnlwfb@163.com (H.N. Li).
Materials & Design 130 (2017) 250–262
Available online 24 May 2017
0264-1275/ © 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MARK