Anchoring Cytokines to Tumor Cells for the Preparation of
Anticancer Vaccines Without Gene Transfection in Mice
*Philippe Nizard, †David Alexandre Gross, *Aurélie Babon, *Alexandre Chenal,
‡Bruno Beaumelle, †Konstadinos Kosmatopoulos, and *Daniel Gillet
*Département d’Ingénierie et d’Etudes des Protéines, CEA-Saclay, †INSERM U487, Institut Gustave Roussy; and ‡UMR 5539
CNRS, Université Montpellier II, France.
Summary: The authors have investigated a new way of combining cytokines with
tumor cells to prepare anticancer vaccines. This method may offer an alternative to
gene therapy approaches. It consists in anchoring recombinant cytokines to the cell
membrane. Attachment is mediated by the transmembrane domain of diphtheria toxin
(T) genetically fused to the cytokine and is triggered by an acid pH pulse. The authors
found that the fusion protein T-hIL-2 anchored to the surface of tumor cells retained
its IL-2 activity while remaining exposed for several days. Interestingly, vaccination of
mice with these modified tumor cells induced a protective antitumor immunity medi-
ated by tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes. This procedure presents several ad-
vantages as compared with the conventional approaches based on the transfection of
tumor cells with cytokine genes. It does not require the culture of tumor cells from the
patients and the selection of transfected clones, it eliminates the safety problems
connected with viral vectors, and it allows the control of the amount of cytokines
delivered with the vaccine. Key Words: Cancer vaccine—Interleukin-2—Diphtheria
toxin—Membrane anchor—Transmembrane domain.
One of the main strategies developed for the prepara-
tion of anticancer vaccines is based on the use of trans-
fected tumor cells expressing cytokines or costimulatory
molecules (1). Their injection in animals gives highly
promising results, and clinical trials in humans have be-
gun (2–6). However, the production of genetically modi-
fied tumor cells in a clinical context suffers from several
drawbacks; for example, some tumor cells are difficult to
transfect, the selection of stable transfectants requires
several days of costly cell culture procedures incompat-
ible with a routine treatment of many patients, the use of
viruses for gene transfer may still be hazardous at the
moment (7–9), and the amount of recombinant proteins
produced by the transfected tumor cells varies dramati-
cally from cell to cell, requiring the selection of clones or
the use of tunable promotors for proper dosage of the
cytokine delivered with the vaccine (1,10).
In an attempt to overcome these problems, we have
investigated a new way of combining cytokines with
tumor cells for the production of antitumor vaccines.
This method takes advantage from the membrane bind-
ing properties of the diphtheria toxin transmembrane do-
main (T). T is a nontoxic 22kD protein domain (11),
which is soluble at neutral pH and which penetrates into
lipid membranes at pH 5 (12). Within the whole toxin,
the function of the T domain is to assist the translocation
of the catalytic domain through the membrane of the
early endosome after the toxin has been internalized by
receptor mediated endocytosis (13). We have shown pre-
viously that the T domain could be used as a pH-
triggered membrane anchor for soluble proteins geneti-
cally fused at its N- or C-terminus (14–16).
We now have studied whether this anchoring system
could be used to attach recombinant cytokines to tumor
Received May 28, 2002; accepted September 16, 2002.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Daniel Gillet, Dé-
partement d’Ingénierie et d’Etudes des Protéines, bat 152, CEA-Saclay,
91191 Gif sur Yvette cedex, France; e-mail: daniel.gillet@cea.fr
Journal of Immunotherapy
26(1):63–71 © 2003 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc., Philadelphia
63