ABSTRACT. Increasing attention to the issue of child
labor has been reflected in codes of conduct that
emerged in the past decade in particular. This paper
examines the way in which multinationals, business
associations, governmental and non-governmental
organizations deal with child labor in their codes.
With a standardized framework, it analyzes 55 codes
drawn up by these different actors to influence firms’
external, societal behavior. The exploratory study
helps to identify the main issues related to child labor
and the use of voluntary instruments such as codes
of conduct. Apart from a specific indication of the
topics covered by the code, especially minimum-age
requirements, this also includes monitoring systems
and monitoring parties. Most important to company
codes are the sanctions imposed on business partners
in case of non-compliance. Severe measures may be
counterproductive as they do not change the under-
lying causes of child labor and can worsen the
situation of the child workers by driving them to
more hazardous work in the informal sector. This
underlines the importance of a broad rather than a
restrictive approach to child labor in codes of conduct.
The paper discusses the implications of this study,
offering suggestions for future research.
KEY WORDS: business associations, child labor,
codes of conduct, international organizations, multi-
national enterprises, non-governmental organizations
ABBREVIATIONS: BSG – Business Support Group;
ILO – International Labor Organization; IO –
International (governmental) Organization; MNE –
Multinational Enterprise; NGO – Non-governmental
Organization; OECD – Organization for Economic
Cooperation and Development; UNICEF – United
Nations Children’s Fund
Introduction
Since the early 20th century, the issue of child
labor has been the subject of widespread regula-
tory and societal attention. After several indus-
trialized countries had adopted laws that limited
the minimum working age of children and their
working conditions, international organizations
were requested to advance similar measures
worldwide. The main vehicle of these interna-
tional attempts has been the International Labor
Organization, created in 1919 with the abolish-
ment of child labor as one of its fundamental
objectives. This was reflected in the adoption of
the Minimum Age Convention (No. 5) in the
same year.
In the course of the century, several other
international initiatives have been taken to
protect children, particularly the 1924
Declaration of Geneva, the creation of UNICEF
(1946), ILO’s 1973 minimum age convention
(No. 146), the 1989 UN Declaration on the
Rights of the Child and, most recently, the 1999
ILO Convention to combat the worst forms of
child labor (No. 182). These different initiatives
aimed to regulate children’s working conditions
in the traditional sense: governments, both
Child Labor and Multinational
Conduct: A Comparison of
International Business and
Ans Kolk
Stakeholder Codes Rob van Tulder
Journal of Business Ethics 36: 291–301, 2002.
© 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Ans Kolk is associate professor in sustainable management
at the University of Amsterdam, Department of
Accountancy and Information Management.
Rob van Tulder is professor in business studies at the
Erasmus University, Department of Business-Society
Management.