RELIABILITY OF A PHOTOGRAPHIC METHOD FOR ASSESSING
STANDING POSTURE OF ELEMENTARY SCHOOL STUDENTS
Jelena Paušić, PhD,
a
Željko Pedišić, MEd,
b
and Dražan Dizdar, PhD
c
ABSTRACT
Objective: A high prevalence of poor standing posture among elementary schoolchildren indicates the need for the
introduction of school-based interventions for improvement of postural alignments. For assessing the effect of
intervention programs, reliable quantitative measures of standing posture should be used. Therefore, the purpose of
this study was to examine the reliability of a photographic method for assessment of standing posture among
elementary schoolchildren.
Methods: The study was conducted on a convenience sample of 273 male students between 10 and 13 years old.
Each subject was photographed in habitual standing posture, 3 times in a front view and 3 times in a side view.
Deviations from ideal postural alignment were calculated with Posture Image Analyzer software and UTHSCSA
ImageTool software. Interitem reliability was estimated using intraclass correlation coefficient.
Results: Intraclass correlation coefficients for posture deviations assessed with Posture Image Analyzer ranged from
0.81 for knee joints deviation and ankle joints deviation in the coronal plane to 0.92 for trunk deviation and knee joints
deviation in the sagittal plane. Intraclass correlation coefficients for posture deviations assessed with UTHSCSA
ImageTool ranged from 0.80 for knee joints deviation in the coronal plane to 0.91 for trunk deviation and knee joints
deviation in the sagittal plane.
Conclusions: This study showed a satisfactory interitem reliability of a photographic method for the assessment of
standing posture among elementary schoolchildren. (J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2010;33:425-431)
Key Indexing Terms: Posture; Reproducibility of Results; Schools; Child
I
deal standing posture should allow for the maintenance
of balance using the least musculoskeletal effort
without a feeling of discomfort. The ideal alignment
of body segments in standing posture should coincide with
a vertical line passing through the center of gravity of the
body.
1
From a lateral view, the ear, axis, shoulder, bodies
of lumbar vertebrae, hip, knee, and the point just in front
of the lateral malleolus should be situated on the same
vertical line.
2
In the sagittal plane, the posture should be
bilaterally symmetrical.
2
Large deviations from ideal postural alignment induce
stress on spinal tissues, resulting in possible headaches,
neck pain, back fatigue, and structural deformities of the
spine, intervertebral discs, and spinal ligaments.
3,4
We
assume that a negative influence of poor standing posture
on health is especially expressed in primary school age.
Namely, in that, period poor standing posture affects spinal
tissues in combination with other risk factors, such as rapid
changes in growth, backpack use, faulty sitting posture, and
the use of nonergonomic school furniture.
5-8
Epidemiologic
studies have shown that posture-related problems are very
common among schoolchildren. Scoliosis was found in
4.2% of schoolchildren aged 8 to 15,
9
whereas 22% of
schoolchildren reported having headaches at least once a
week.
10
We assume that the high prevalence of such
diagnoses could be, among other factors, a consequence of
poor standing posture.
Kratěnová et al
11
found that 38% of schoolchildren who
were 11 years old had poor posture, which indicates a
potential need for the introduction of school-based inter-
ventions for improvement of postural faults. Such inter-
ventions were well accepted among elementary school
students.
12-14
Results of the abovementioned study
13
concerning effects of school-based interventions on chil-
dren's posture are somewhat limited because of the
qualitative nature of the methods used for postural
a
Assistant Professor, Faculty of Kinesiology, University of
Split, Split, Croatia.
b
Research Associate, Faculty of Kinesiology, University of
Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia.
c
Assistant Professor, Faculty of Kinesiology, University of
Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia.
Submit requests for reprints to: Željko Pedišić, MEd, Research
Associate, Faculty of Kinesiology, University of Zagreb, Horva-
čanski Zavoj 15, Zagreb, Croatia 21000
(e-mail: zeljko.pedisic@kif.hr).
Paper submitted October 13, 2009; in revised form February
27, 2010; accepted March 29, 2010.
0161-4754/$36.00
Copyright © 2010 by National University of Health Sciences.
doi:10.1016/j.jmpt.2010.06.002
425