http://elynsgroup.com
Copyright: © 2016 Franco IL, et al.
http://dx.doi.org/10.19104/jorm.2016.114
Open Access Case Report
J Orth Rhe Sp Med
Journal of Orthopedics, Rheumatology and Sports Medicine
Page 1 of 5
ISSN: 2470-9824
Percutaneous Radiofrequency Thermal Ablation Treatment of
Recurrent Bone Giant Cell Tumor
Ignacio L. Franco
1
*, Angel B. Horcajadas
2
, Jose Martel
1
and Eduardo Ortiz
3
1
Department of Radiology, Hospital Universitario Fundacion de Alcorcon, Madrid, Spain
2
Department of Musculoskeletal Radiology, Hospital Universitario Fundacion de Alcorcon, Madrid, Spain
3
Department of Traumatology and Orthopedic Surgery, Hospital Universitario La Paz, Madrid, Spain
Abstract
Percutaneous Radiofrequency Thermal Ablation (PRFTA) is the
method of choice to treat most of the cases of osteoid osteoma. The
Good results on other benign bone tumors as osteoblastoma and
chondroblastoma have been reported. The treatment for bone Giant Cell
Tumor (GCT) is surgical resection. The PRFTA has not been previously
described for recurrent GCT in the literature. We reported four recurrent
GCTs from our institution, successfully treated with PRFTA (from 2009
to 2014), located in the lateral cuneiform bone, the distal epiphysis of
tibia, the greater tuberosity of femur and the coxal bone involving the hip
joint. The previous percutaneous CT guided 11G biopsy confirmed the
diagnosis in all of the cases. The patients were under general anesthesia
or deep sedation in the CT room. The radiofrequency electrode was
inserted through a bone introducer needle and heated at 90°C for three
to five minutes. There were no complications, with rapid recovery of the
patients.
Introduction
Surgery remains as the primary treatment for the bone
GCT. The GCT recurrence occurs in 2–25% of cases [1,2]. When
surgery is not possible or could be associated with excessive
morbidity, denosumab (a fully human monoclonal antibody to
RANKL (Receptor activator of nuclear factor kappa-B ligand), a
key mediator of osteoclast activity) is a good treatment option.
The optimal length of treatment and schedule of denosumab is
unknown, but recurrences after apparent complete responses have
been observed after stopping denosumab, and long-term follow-up
of denosumab treatment may reveal unrecognized effects [3].
On the other hand, recent advance in minimally invasive
therapies are adding further tools for tumor management. For
instance, percutaneous radiofrequency thermal ablation (PRFTA)
has been reported in the literature as a successful treatment for
hepatic tumor as well as for the treatment of benign bone tumors
[4–6]. However, we have not found any reference in the literature
to this treatment modality for recurrent GCT, and there are only a
small number of case reports on GCT [6,7].
The Radiofrequency ablation is based on heating tumor cells
to temperatures higher than 60°C until they are killed. It uses an
electromagnetic 300 to 500 KHz frequency alternating current,
carried by an image guided electrode which is introduced into
the tumor. The current phase changes induce local ionic agitation,
which triggers molecular friction movements responsible for a rise
in temperature. The temperature increases around the electrode
and the heat is distributed by diffusion.
The primary purpose of this study is to describe our experience
of PRFTA treatment in bone GCT recurrences, where further
surgery would have been too aggressive.
Received Date: July 25, 2016, Accepted Date: October 28, 2016, Published Date: November 07, 2016.
*Corresponding author: Ignacio Lopez-Vidaur Franco, Department of Radiology, Hospital Universitario Fundacion de Alcorcon, Madrid, Spain, E-mail:
ilopezvidaur@gmail.com
Materials and Methods
We reported the cases of four patients from our institution with
GCTs recurrences, who where successfully treated with PRFTA
(from 2009 to 2014). The study was approved by the Institutional
Medical Ethical Review Board. All patients were provided with the
relevant information and signed the relevant consent forms before
the procedure took place.
The recurrent GCTs were located in:
Case 1: The lateral cuneiform bone of the right tarsus
Case 2: The distal epiphysis of the left tibia involving the
subchondral cortical bone
Case 3: The greater tuberosity of the right femur
Case 4: The iliac bone which included a fracture with of the
subchondral cortical of acetabulum and tumor growth into the hip
joint.
All four patients had been diagnosed with bone giant cell tumor
diagnosed by percutaneous CT guided biopsy and subsequent
surgery.
Prior surgical treatment had been performed in all patients
with intra-lesion extended resection and curettage, in addition to
high speed burr, pulsatile lavage, phenol, and reconstruction with
bone allograft or cementplasty. Case 1 was treated surgically twice
before PRFTA and case 2 was treated three times. Case 3 and 4
underwent surgery once. Recurrence of bone GCT was confirmed
by percutaneous biopsy in all cases.
The Percutaneous CT guided by radiofrequency thermal ablation
(RFTA) was performed in all four patients. Before undergoing RF
ablation, signed consent forms were obtained from each patient. All
candidates were informed with regards to alternative treatments.
The procedures were carried out under general anesthesia or deep
sedation in the CT room.
The technique used was the same as has been described in the
literature for osteoid osteoma [4,5]. We reached the bone lesion
under CT guidance with an 11−13 gauge (G) introducer bone biopsy
needle. The stylet of the needle was removed and exchanged for a
17 G monopolar RF electrode (Cool-tip Covidien RAF System). The
CT image ensured the right placement of the electrode active tip
(7–10 mm) inside the lesion. Radiofrequency-activation time was
three to five minutes providing that the core temperature reached
90°C (Figure 1). Cooling activation was not necessary due to the
small size of the recurrence.
The monitoring and follow up with CT and MRI was performed
for 18 months to five years after treatment.