Copyright © FrancoAngeli
N.B: Copia ad uso personale. È vietata la riproduzione (totale o parziale) dell’opera con qualsiasi
mezzo effettuata e la sua messa a disposizione di terzi, sia in forma gratuita sia a pagamento.
Powerless to parent; powerless to protect:
The experiences of alienated parents in the UK
Sue Whitcombe
Parental alienation is the unwarranted denigration or rejection of a parent where there was a
previous loving relationship. Despite thirty years of study establishing its aetiology, preva-
lence, appropriate interventions and outcomes for children, parental alienation remains a
highly contentious concept in the UK. Additionally, there has been minimal exploration of
the experiences of alienated parents across the globe. A recent Q analysis uncovered the
subjective and intersubjective experiences of British alienated parents. An unexpected con-
sensus became apparent which merited further analysis of the data. Through this phenome-
nological exploration of the participants’ narratives, a pervasive sense of “powerlessness”
emerged. The source of this felt sense of powerlessness is considered and recommendations
for policy and practice are suggested.
Key words: parental alienation, family conflict, psychological harm, family law, parent.
1. Introduction
Parental alienation (PA) is characterised by a child’s strong alignment
with one parent whilst rejecting a relationship with the other, despite a prior
normal, loving, warm relationship. This rejection seems unwarranted based
on a history of normal-range parenting, in the absence of abuse or violence,
and is most usually a feature of high conflict relationship breakdown. Since
the 1980s, the symptomatic behaviours and underlying psychological pro-
cesses in an alienated child have been identified (Baker, 2005a; Baker &
Darnall, 2006; Clawar & Rivlin, 1991; Dunne & Hedrick, 1994; Gardner,
1985; Johnston, Campbell, & Mayes, 1985; Kelly & Johnston, 2001; Ko-
petski, 1998; Waldron & Joanis, 1996; Wallerstein & Kelly, 1980). Key
features are a child’s irrational anxiety and refusal or resistance to contact
with one parent, or contact which is characterised by extreme withdrawal, or
gross hatred and animosity (Baker, 2014; Bernet, von Boch-Galhau, Baker,
& Morrison, 2010; Fidler & Bala, 2010; Johnston, 2003). Research has
identified increased clinical, emotional and behavioural problems in al-
ienated children as well as risks to a child’s psychological and emotional
Dr. Sue Whitcombe, CPsychol AFBPsS, HCPC registered counselling psychologist. Fami-
ly Psychology Solutions CIC, Wales.
Indirizzare le richieste a Sue Whitcombe (sue@suewhitcombe.co.uk).
Pervenuto: settembre 2016
Accettato: dicembre 2016
47
Maltrattamento e abuso all’infanzia, Vol. 19, n. 1, marzo 2017, pp. 47-66
ISSN 1591-4267, ISSNe 1972-5140 DOI: 10.3280/MAL2017-001004