International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 04 Issue: 07 | July -2017 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072
© 2017, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 5.181 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 980
Optimization of Thermal Performance of Double Pipe Heat Exchanger
using Mechanical Turbulators
Jashanjot Singh Cheema
1
, Sandeep Salodkar
2
, Gurjeet Singh
3
, S K Soni
4
1
M.E. Scholar, Department of Mechanical engineering, PEC University of Technology, Chandigarh
23
Assistant Professor, Department of Mechanical engineering, PEC University of Technology, Chandigarh
4
Associate Professor, Department of Mechanical engineering, PEC University of Technology, Chandigarh
---------------------------------------------------------------------***---------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract - This research work is focused on Optimization of
Double Pipe Counter Flow Heat Exchanger. The Coiled
Mechanical Turbulators are inserted in pipe of Heat exchanger
and experiments are performed by varying Spacing between
Turbulators, Mass flow rates of Hot and cold waters. Values of
Overall Heat Transfer coefficient and pressure drop are
obtained. Taguchi Method was used to optimize Overall Heat
Transfer coefficient & Pressure drop individually and later
Grey Relation Analysis (GRA) has been employed for
simultaneous optimization of multi-response characteristics
i.e. Overall Heat Transfer coefficient and Pressure Drop.
Research provided the optimum values for individually of
Overall Heat Transfer coefficient and Pressure drop and also
optimum values for both simultaneously. For the Overall Heat
Transfer Coefficient, it was observed that optimal combination
of process parameters are mc is 1500lph, mh is 2000lph, pitch
is 2cm and optimum value for Overall Heat Transfer
coefficient is 7486.57 w/m
2
k and pressure drop at these
parameters is 3014.78N/m
2
.For the Pressure Drop it was
observed that Optimal combination of process parameters are
mc is 1500lph, mh is 1500lph, pitch is 10cm and optimum value
for pressure drop is 1785.17 N/m
2
and Overall Heat Transfer
coefficient at these parameters is 4682.17 w/m
2
k. Using GRA,
optimization of the multi response has been converted into
single response called grey relation grade and the optimal
combination of the process parameters for multiple
performance optimization has been found to be mc is 1500lph,
mh is 1700lph, pitch is 6cm and the optimal value for Overall
Heat Transfer coefficient s 5803.994 w/m
2
k and Pressure drop
is 2408.8N/m
2
.
Key Words: Heat Enhancement, Mechanical
Turbulators, Optimization, Taguchi, Grey Analysis
Abbreviations and Symbols
Abbreviation Description
SN Signal to Noise
lph Litre Per Hour
HP Horse Power
KW Kilowatt
mc
Mass flow Rate of cold
water
mh Mass flow rate of Hot water
Symbol Description
▲P Pressure Drop
U Overall Heat Transfer
coefficient
Q Heat
m Meter
cm Centimetre
N SN Normalized SN ratio
ξ Grey Relation Coefficient
ἠ Grey Relation Grade
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Heat Transfer Enhancement Techniques
The augmentation of heat transfer is defined as the process
to increase the heat transfer rate in heat exchanger. This
process also helps to redesign the heat exchanger by
reducing the size of heat exchanger but also high initial
investment. Broadly the devices which are used to enhance
the heat transfer rate in pipe of heat exchanger are called
turbulators. And these turbulators are divided into two
categories Active and Passive.
Active Techniques for Heat Transfer Enhancement-Active
techniques of heat transfer enhancement are those which
require external power ex. surface vibration, fluid vibration,
injection, suction, and electric or acoustic fields.
Passive Techniques for the Heat Transfer Enhancement-The
passive techniques of heat transfer enhancement are those
which does not require any external power for there
working. These can be applied by installing the turbulence
generators or turbulators, e.g. the insertion of twisted stripes