A Versatile Lattice Simulator for Fluid-Solid Noncatalytic
Reactions in Complex Media
Alessandra Adrover*
,†,§
and Massimiliano Giona
‡,§
Dipartimento di Ingegneria Chimica, Universita ` di Roma “La Sapienza”, Via Eudossiana 18,
00184 Roma, Italy, Dipartimento di Ingegneria Chimica, Universita ` di Cagliari, and Piazza d’Armi,
09123 Cagliari, Italy, and Centro Interuniversitario sui Sistemi Disordinati e sui Frattali nell’Ingegneria
Chimica, Universita ´ di Roma, Via Eudossiana 18, 00184 Roma, Italy
A versatile lattice simulator for fluid-solid noncatalytic reactions is developed in detail in order
to study linear, nonlinear, and nonisothermal kinetics in complex media, in the presence of
multicomponent diffusion and n-solid reactant species. The simulator is based on a time-splitting
algorithm for the diffusion and for the reaction steps. The simulator is quantitatively checked
in many different cases involving initially nonporous particles constituted by a solid reactant
dispersed in an inert matrix. The influence of spatial correlation properties in the case of uniform
and nonuniform solid reactant distribution is analyzed in detail.
1. Introduction
Fluid-solid reactions represent a basic mechanism
in many industrial processes, from coal gasification to
ore leaching. Over the last 20 years, many authors have
studied the application of percolation models and of
other concepts derived from the theory of disordered
systems to interpret the relationship between the
macroscopic overall kinetics and structural properties
of the solid matrices, especially in regard to porous
solids (Sahimi, 1994).
The first attempt to apply percolation models was
performed by Mohanty et al. (1982). Subsequently,
Reyes and Jensen (1986a,b, 1987) modeled different
gas-solid reaction (char gasification, sulfation of cal-
cined limestones) in both reaction-controlled and diffu-
sion-controlled regimes. The estimate of the structural
properties and of effective transport parameters comes
from the assumption of a Cayley-tree topology in the
pore network (Yortsos and Sharma, 1986; Kerstein and
Bug, 1986).
These models are effective continuum models, in
which the balance equations for the fluid reactant are
written for continua, and the effective transport param-
eters and the macroscopic description (and temporal
evolution) of the pore network (accessible porosity,
accessible surface area) are obtained from percolation
models or from other models of disorder.
There are several drawbacks to continuum models for
disordered media. The first is that they may not be
valid in the presence of structures possessing infinite-
correlation length. This occurs, for example, in gas-
solid reactions in the proximity of the fragmentation
threshold (since fragmentation can be regarded as a
critical phenomenon).
Moreover, all the parameters (transport and struc-
tural) entering into hybrid models are based on a priori
assumptions about the pore-network structure and/or
distribution of the solid reactant within an inert matrix.
In particular, transport and structural parameters are
generally obtained starting from simple (and uncorre-
lated) models of disorder (the classical site and/or bond
percolation models) or from unrealistic topologies (such
as Cayley trees, which are loopless and nonfinite in
dimension; see Aharony and Stauffer (1992)). The
limitation of these assumptions is that both the pore-
network structure of real materials and/or the distribu-
tion of solid reactants within the pore-network matrix
are spatially correlated in real materials. Although the
spatial correlations are usually short-range (and the
universality class is therefore the same as the corre-
sponding uncorrelated structures), the structural prop-
erties, for noncritical structures (i.e., not at the perco-
lation threshold), may be different, as shown by Adrover
and Giona (1996) for permeability. A detailed discus-
sion of this issue is developed in Section 5.
Over the last 10 years, the growth of interest in the
influence of the structural features of porous and
granular materials on global transport and reaction
properties together with the availability of fast comput-
ers possessing large memory capacity has stimulated
the development of lattice models of porous structures.
Lattice models for noncatalytic fluid-solid reactions
were developed by Kerstein and Edwards (1987) and
by Sahimi and Tsotsis (1987, 1988). Kerstein and
Edwards (1987) modeled the char oxidation process as
the ignition and burnout (i.e., removal) of solid bonds.
Upon ignition, a solid bond is assigned a randomly
selected burning time drawn from a distribution func-
tion depending on the mass of the fragment. The
distinguishing features of the film-diffusion-limited
regime of char oxidation are incorporated into the solid-
bond ignition criterion and into the dependence of the
particle-burning rate per unit surface area on the mass
(i.e., the number of solid bonds) of a given subcluster.
In the model developed by Sahimi and Tsotsis (1987,
1988), diffusion is simulated by means of a random walk
of the fluid reactant, which is controlled by the local
bond conductances (diffusivities), and reaction is a
random event occurring with a probability depending
on the rate of reaction (and on temperature). The
simulation refers, however, to isothermal conditions.
This kind of model takes advantage of the basic analogy
between transport (diffusion) and random walk, as
widely applied in the literature on elementary reactions
in disordered (fractal) media.
Lattice models can be classified in terms of two major
* Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Phone: +39-6-44585892. Fax: +39-6-44585339. E-mail: alex@
giona2.ing.uniroma1.it.
†
Universita ` di Roma “La Sapienza”.
‡
Universita ` di Cagliari.
§
Centro Interuniveristario sui Sistemi Disordinati e sui
Frattali nell’Ingegneria Chimica.
4993 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1997, 36, 4993-5009
S0888-5885(97)00164-4 CCC: $14.00 © 1997 American Chemical Society