The Australian Economic Review, vol. 39, no. 1, pp. 14–34
©
2006 The University of Melbourne, Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research
Published by Blackwell Publishing Asia Pty Ltd
Abstract
This article develops a microsimulation model
of the Australian housing market that has ten-
ure choice as its principal focus. The article
sheds light on the role played by relative
prices, wealth and borrowing constraints in
shaping housing tenure choices. We explore
the model’s capabilities as an aid to policy
making by reporting the findings from an im-
pact analysis of grant programs designed to
ease the transition of first home buyers into
owner occupation. We find a large demand for
home ownership that is not met because of bor-
rowing constraints. The need to meet financial
institutions’ down payment requirements is
particularly important. Government grants
made available to first home buyers will ease
down payment requirements, but the formal in-
cidence of such a subsidy is found to be inequi-
table among potential first home buyers, and
its impact is largely to bring forward purchase
decisions.
1. Introduction
This article develops a microsimulation model
of the Australian housing market whose princi-
pal focus is to predict the housing tenure con-
sequences of housing policy actions and
housing market shocks. Our research is moti-
vated by two aims. First, the model is designed
to shed light on the role played by relative
prices, wealth and borrowing constraints in
shaping housing tenure choices. The microsim-
ulation approach has the virtue of facilitating
analysis of the types of households that are vul-
nerable to rationing due to borrowing con-
straints, which have been emphasised in more
recent studies of tenure choice (Gyourko
2003). Second, the microsimulation model is
capable of estimating the impact of govern-
ment intervention on housing market out-
comes, and tenure choice in particular. We
explore the model’s policy impact measure-
ment capabilities by reporting the findings
from analyses of an Australian federal govern-
ment grant program, introduced to offset the
net price effect from the indirect tax changes
that were part of the federal government’s July
2000 New Tax System reforms, and thereby
ease first home buyers’ transition into owner
occupation under the new fiscal arrangements.
The First Home Owner Grant (FHOG) pro-
gram offered the first home buyers of newly
constructed property a grant of up to $14 000, a
sum that has subsequently been wound back to
$7000.
Our microsimulation model brings together
the supply and demand sides of the Australian
housing market by estimating the prices and
Microsimulation Modelling of Tenure Choice and Grants to
Promote Home Ownership
Gavin Wood, Richard Watson and Paul Flatau*
School of Social Sciences and Planning, RMIT University; Treasury, State
Government of Western Australia; and Murdoch Business School, Murdoch
University, respectively
* We are grateful to the Australian Housing and Urban Re-
search Institute for providing financial assistance to sup-
port the research upon which the article is based. Judith
Cockburn-Campbell, Matthew Forbes, Sarah Hickson and
Rachel Ong provided valuable research assistance. The au-
thors are grateful to Pat Hendershott and an anonymous
referee for helpful comments and Alice Stoakes who ably
assisted with the preparation of the manuscript. The normal
disclaimer applies.