Different cancer cell lines resistant to the same drug
exhibit differences in folate pathway dynamics
Amrisha Bhosle and Nagasuma Chandra
*
Department of Biochemistry
Indian Institute of Science
Bangalore, India
*
Email: nchandra@biochem.iisc.ernet.in
Abstract—Use of methotrexate (MTX), a widely used anti-
cancer drug which targets primarily dihydrofolate reductase
(DHFR) in the folate pathway is being limited by the emergence
of resistance. Despite a large number of studies, a quantitative
understanding of target pathway dynamics in resistant cancers
is majorly lacking. In this work, we integrated gene expression
data from different MTX-resistant cancer cell lines into kinetic
models to study dynamics of the folate metabolic pathway. Given
that all cell lines are derived from human cancers, the pathway
is essentially the same consisting of 11 reactions catalyzed by the
same set of enzymes and 1 non-enzymatic reaction. Kinetic models
emulating pathway dynamics in MTX-untreated, MTX-treated-
sensitive and MTX-treated-resistant conditions were generated
and model behaviour at steady state was analysed with respect
to concentrations of six folate metabolites and fluxes through the
12 reactions. We observed differences in steady-state properties
across these cell lines even in the absence of MTX inhibition. More
interestingly, the response of sensitive and resistant variants of
each cancer type was also seen to vary in simulations of MTX-
inhibition. However, accumulation of dihydrofolate at steady state
for all sensitive cell lines along and a decrease towards normal
levels for their resistant counterparts remained a common feature
in most cases. Metabolic control analysis performed to identify
crucial flux controlling elements in the pathway indicated that
the enzymes methenyltetrahydrofolate cyclohydrolase (MTCH)
and phosphoribosylglycinamide formyltransferase (PGT) could
be targeted in combination with DHFR in MTX-resistant cancers
for improved therapy.
Keywords—Methotrexate effect, Gene expression profile, Kinetic
model, Metabolic control analysis
I. I NTRODUCTION
Drug resistance is a major problem in the chemothera-
peutic management of cancer. Resistance to anti-cancer drugs
decreases drug efficacy and facilitates disease progression.
It can be broadly classified into two categories: acquired or
intrinsic. Mutations in drug target and increased production
of target protein are two of the common mechanisms of
acquired drug resistance. Methotrexate (MTX; 4-amino- N10-
methylpteroylglutamic acid), a notable antineoplastic agent
is a potent competitive inhibitor of dihydrofolate reductase
(DHFR); an enzyme in the folate pathway. MTX and its polyg-
We thank the Department of Biotechnology (DBT) and the Mathematical
Biology Programe supported by the Department of Science and Technology
(DST), Government of India, for financial support. The use of facilities at
Department of Biochemistry, Indian Institute of Science is also gratefully
acknowledged.
lutamated forms also inhibit other enzymes in the same path-
way such as thymidylate synthase (TS) non-competitively and
AICAR transformylase (AICART) and GAR transformylase
(PGT) competitively [1]. Chemotherapy with MTX has been
rendered ineffective due to DHFR over-expression in resistant
cancers [2], [3] and binding site mutations that reduce MTX
binding affinity [4], [5]. This necessitates the development of
new drug targeting strategies that can be used to alleviate if
not obliterate the effects of resistance.
The folate pathway lies at the interface of protein and
nucleic acid metabolism pathways and therefore is of enor-
mous pharmacological importance. Three most essential folate
metabolites include 5-methyl THF required for methionine
synthesis, 5, 10-methylene THF that provides C1 units for
synthesis of deoxythymidine monophosphate (dTMP) and 10-
formyl THF that is utilized as a co-factor in de novo purine
synthesis reactions. Inhibition of this pathway depletes the
cell of dTMP required for DNA synthesis thereby halting cell
proliferation. Studies reporting change in pathway dynamics on
inhibition by small molecules have been carried out employing
mass spectrometric analyses and mathematical modelling [6],
[7], [8].
Dynamics of complex biochemical pathways can be studied
through numeric integration of inter-connected enzymatic reac-
tions represented as a mathematical model consisting of ordi-
nary differential equations. Different parameters in the model
such as rate constants, V
max
and K
M
affect system behavior
to different extents which can be measured by performing
sensitivity analysis on the model. Metabolic Control Analysis
(MCA) [9]; a form of sensitivity analysis is a powerful
technique that can be used to quantify the contribution of every
parameter in a mathematical model that captures a biological
phenomemon such as drug resistance. MCA offers a scaled
sensitivity analysis through Control coefficients which measure
the response of a particular system variable to infinitesimal
changes in rate of an enzymatic reaction which can be altered
by chemotherapeutic agents. Use of MCA in identification of
drug targets has been discussed in several studies [10], [11],
[12].
In this study we generated models for seven cancer cell
lines by incorporating (1) gene expression data for the 11 en-
zymes in the pathway and (2) changes in enzymatic parameters
due to enzyme inhibition in the basic folate pathway kinetic
model [8]. Model behavior at steady state was studied for all
cancer cell lines under three conditions viz. MTX-untreated
(MU), MTX-treated-sensitive (MTS) and MTX-treated-resistant
2014 IEEE International Conference on Bioinformatics and Biomedicine
978-1-4799-5669-2/14/$31.00 ©2014 IEEE 209