Injury, Int. J. Care Injured 44 S3 (2013) S46–S48
Introduction
Repetitive impact injuries to the elbow of goalkeepers caused
by the ball hitting the fully extended distal part of a forearm have
been well described during handball sporting activities.
1
Water
polo also has strong similarities to handball. It was previously
believed that such impact injuries to the elbow are caused by
excessive hyperextension load. A newly published study found,
through video analysis, that elbow valgus loading is a more likely
cause of this injury.
2
Many authors have suggested that repetitive
valgus force applied to the capitellum is the main etiological
factor in osteochondritis disecans (OCD) of capitellum.
3,4
We report on 2 cases of acute hyperextension/valgus elbow
injuries in two adult, male national team water polo goalkeepers.
Both were healthy and had never had any major injuries to the
elbow. The hypothesis of this paper is that incomplete cure
of acute elbow injuries may result in OCD due to inadequate
treatment.
Case reports
Case 1
An 18-year-old right-handed Caucasian male goalkeeper of
the national water polo team sustained an impact injury to the
right elbow caused by ball striking a fully extended distal part of
the forearm. The injury occurred during training session. Because
of sharp pain, predominantly in the posterior part of the elbow,
he was taken out of the training session and examined by the
team physician. Initially diagnosis was a hyperextension injury
to the elbow. He was immediately treated by using RICE (rest,
ice, compression, elevation) procedure and has been ordered to
undergo a further medical examination the next day.
The next day evaluation included a clinical examination and
magnetic resonance imaging of the right elbow.
The “chief complaint” was diffuse soreness of the elbow and
minor loss of range of motion.
The pain was not spread to another area, and was exacerbated
by activity. He lost a few degrees to full extension of elbow for
both active and passive movement. An attempt at a full ROM
increased the pain in the antecubital fossa and posterior part of
the elbow. Supination and pronation motion was approximately
80° in both directions.
Elbow did not significantly swell and the area around it did
not show any ecchymosis. Direct palpation of the antecubital
fossa was slightly painful. All other findings were normal. Mayo
Elbow Score was 85.
Magnetic resonance imaging of the right elbow showed
bone contusion to the posterior part of capitellum and a partial
rupture of the anconeus muscle (Figure 1).
The injured athlete did not have any previous similar elbow
injury. He was healthy and he was not taking any medication.
He was treated conservatively with cryotherapy, physical
therapy and rehabilitation. During the first week with
physiotherapy the soft tissue swelling was reduced with gentle
lymphatic drainage, laser therapy, ice pack around the elbow
(3-4 times per day for 5 min). He started to perform gentle
passive, active-assisted and active exercise of the elbow (forearm
pronation, supination, flexion) and wrist (flexion, extension).
During the second week the athlete started with rapid progression
of upper extremity muscle strengthening including shoulder
concentric and forearms muscles isotonic exercise (concentric
KEYWORDS
Repetitive elbow injury
Water polo
Goalkeeper
Osteochondritis disecans of capitellum
Hyperextension
ABSTRACT
We report on 2 cases of hyperextension/valgus elbow injuries in two adult male national team water polo
goalkeepers. Both were healthy and had never sustained any major injuries of the elbow. Mechanism
and type of injury in both of them was identical. Different medical treatment protocols of these injuries
possibly have led to different outcomes, with one of them developing osteochondritis dissecans (OCD).
Inadequate medical treatment of acute impact elbow injuries could lead to osteochondritis disecans of
the elbow in top-level adult male water polo goalkeepers.
© 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Acute hyperextension/valgus trauma to the elbow in top-level adult male water
polo goalkeepers: a cause of osteochondritis disecans of the capitellum?
Eduard Rod
a,
*, Alan Ivkovic
a,b
, Igor Boric
a
, Sasa Jankovic
b
, Andrej Radic
a
, Damir Hudetz
a,b
a
St Catherine Specialty Hospital, Bracak 8, Zabok, Croatia
b
University Hospital “Sveti Duh”, Sveti Duh 64, Zagreb, Croatia
* Corresponding author at: St Catherine Specialty Hospital, Bracak 8, Zabok,
Croatia. Tel.: +385 49 204 867; Fax: +385 91 244 55 81.
E-mail address: eduardrod1508@gmail.com (E. Rod).
0020-1383/$ – see front matter © 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect
Injury
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/injury