Journal of Medical Education and Training
Short Communication Open Access
Using Simulation to Assist in
Treating the Patient who is
Transgender
Bernadette Riley* and Gina Riley
Clinical Professor of Adolescent Special Education, City University of New
York - Hunter College, USA
*Corresponding author: Bernadette Riley, Email: bernadette18@yahoo.com
Received: 18 April 2017; Accepted: 01 September 2017; Published: 09
September 2017
Transgender patients have special needs in regards to health care,
and studies have shown that there are “disparities in health and access
to healthcare for sexual and gender minorities” [1]. Discrimination
exists for transgender patients, whether it is due to provider discomfort
or provider being unfamiliar with this patient population. Either way
both can be identiied and rectiied by a simulated experience with a
transgender patient.
Transgender identity is the term used to “describe a person’s
fundamental sense of being men, women, or of indeterminate sex” [2].
Gender Dysphoria occurs when there is psychological distress which
comes from a patients’ gender at birth [3]. Gender Identity Disorder
(GID) is a psychiatric diagnosis that occurs when an individual
wishes to be another sex then the one he/she is born with [4]. There is
psychological stress with that occurs with this disorder. Transgendered
patients “desire to live [as] a member of the gender opposite to assigned
sex at birth” [4]. Transgendered patients who were born as males and
transition to females are referred to as MTF, and patients who were
born female and transitioned to males are known as FTM.
The transgender patient has speciic health care needs. With a
MTF transgender patient who did not have sex reassignment surgery,
doctors must be concerned with typically male cancers and problems.
According to the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
(ACOG), the “age appropriate screenings for male to female breast and
prostate cancer is appropriate for MTF transgender patients” [5].
For the transgender patient who is transitioning to another sex and
using hormones, each hormone has its own risks associated with it.
Use of estrogen in MTF patients increases the risk of thromboembolic
disease, breast cancer, cardiovascular disease, cerebrovascular disease,
and migraines [4]. Laboratory abnormalities such as high prolactin
levels and high liver enzymes are also seen. Doctors who prescribe
these hormones must be aware and monitor for the signs and symptoms
of these diseases.
For the transgender patient using testosterone replacement for FTM
transitioning, they are at increased risks for breast and uterine cancer,
polycythmia, and increase in liver enzymes [4]. These patients should
have appropriate lab work on a continual basis to monitor for these side
effects. Providers taking care of these patients should be familiar with
these risks.
Simulated cases exposing a resident to a transgendered patient
can help the resident feel more comfortable interacting with a
transgendered patient. According to a study done in March 2011 by
the Institute of Medicine, it is important to identify patients who are
transgender, in order to establish health risk, and treat accordingly [6].
Having residents get used to asking patients if they are male, female
or other, and what their sexual orientation is would be appropriate and
can help identify the gaps in transgender health care [6]. Asking about
a patient’s sexual identity can open a dialogue where the patient can
feel comfortable sharing with a physician. By starting the conversation,
the provider is establishing a nonjudgmental and open conversation
Copyright © 2017 The Authors. Published by Scientiic Open Access Journals
LLC.
[6]. A suggestion given by the ACOG is to have all patients ill out
a questionnaire where a patient can circle what gender assignment of
male, female or transgender they feel best its with their identity [5].
Transgender patients should feel welcome in the ofice and hospital
setting. Getting familiar with issues facing transgender patients can be
made possible through simulation training. Having residents (and all
members of healthcare staff) go through a session with a transgender
patient or mannequin can help assess how comfortable the resident feels
and can provide videotaped proof of training for this speciic patient
population. A standardized patient playing the transgender patient can
also give feedback on how they felt as the patient.
A typical simulated case would include a transgender patient encounter
with the resident where the patient presents a complaint, and the resident
goes through the session as he/she would with a real patient. The session
is videotaped, and after the session the debrieing begins. The resident,
faculty facilitation, and the standardized patient watch the video and
discuss the case during the debrief. At the debrieing session, the resident
not only gets to self assess their interaction, but also gets to hear what
the simulated patient felt and thought about the resident’s behavior. The
session can help explore issues speciic to treating transgender patient as
well as further explore issues of cultural competence.
During the session the resident can see if they address speciic
transgender patient population issues. Transgender patients have a
higher incidence of HIV, STIs, and drug use [7] than other members of
the American population. Tobacco use is especially prevalent among the
LGBTQ population, and those identiied as LGBTQ are more likely to
suffer from mental illness [8]. During a simulated session, the resident
can ensure they are taking the steps to provide appropriate preventative
care for their simulated transgender patient [9]. The simulated case
may also feature a transgender patient who is taking hormones during
their transition, and the resident can see if they address the fact that
transgendered persons exposed to hormone replacement have speciic
health issues [10]. During the simulated case a resident can become
familiar with the speciic problems a transgender person faces, and can
gauge how comfortable they are in addressing these problems.
If a resident is not comfortable in speaking with a transgender
individual, simple patient encounters can become challenging. A
resident who is not exposed to training with different patient populations,
can stumble on things like what pronoun to use when discussing with
a patient. In a simulated session the resident, as well as staff can get
comfortable with asking the transgender patient questions, and with
treating them. As described in an article by Klein et al, “primary care
physicians are well suited to provide [transgender] care, especially
those with exposure in the areas of mental health, hormone therapy,
and cardiovascular risk reduction” [11].
Studies have shown that transgender patients have limited access to
health care resources, and are often treated with prejudice by physicians
[12]. According to the American Academy of Family Physicians
recommended Curriculum Guidelines for Family Medicine Residents,
it is important to increase an awareness, not only in our own feelings on
transgender patients, but also in our behavior towards LGBTQ patients
in general [12]. A simulated session could provide opportunities where
a physician in training can be exposed to a transgender patient and can
see if they exhibit signs of “unconscious or implicit bias” [12].
Getting familiar with a transgender patients’ journey can also help
the physician understand the psychological needs of the transgender
patient [13]. A study by Bockting et al, on “Stigma, Mental Health,
and Resilience in an Online Sample of the US Transgender Population”