1
Ideas and Politics in Social Science Research
Ideas and Politics
Daniel Béland and Robert Henry Cox
Across the social sciences, ideas are increasingly recognized as major factors in
politics. One could go so far as to say that, as we do in this volume, ideas are a primary source of
political behavior. Our contention here is that ideas shape how we understand political problems,
give definition to our goals and strategies, and are the currency we use to communicate about
politics. By giving definition to our values and preferences, ideas provide us with interpretive
frameworks that make us see some facts as important and others as less so. In turn, this has
serious consequences for how we understand the role of interests in politics. Instead of seeing
politics as the contest among people who have clear and stable interests and develop strategies to
pursue them, this volume develops a vision of politics as the struggle for power and control
among people who are motivated by a myriad of ideas. These might include their perceived
interests, but also their ideals, their pride, their fears, and so on. In addition, the ideas people
share in their communications with those around them inform not only their belief in what they
want, but what they deem to be appropriate, legitimate, and proper.
What, then, are ideas? Despite the attention to the subject, there seems to be ambiguity
and disagreement about basic definitions. For us, ideas are causal beliefs. This simple definition
involves many discrete dimensions. First, as beliefs, ideas are products of cognition. They are
produced in our minds, and are connected to the material world only via our interpretations of
our surroundings. Our minds can create ideas from any of a multitude of sensory perceptions, or
the mind can create ideas based on no connection to reality at all. How else could we know and
believe in things we cannot see or touch? Second, as causal beliefs, ideas posit connections