World Academia
Org Publication
Modern Journal Of Language and Literature , Vol. 1 , No. 2 /3 ,
October /November 2011
ISSN : 2251- 6956
© Word Academia Org. Publication, UK. London
All rights reserved
www.world-academia.com 1
Deframing Theory & Poetry: from William
Shakespeare to E. E. Cummings
Yasser Khamees Ragab Aman, Minia University, yass712000@yahoo.com
Abstract
This paper introduces the theory of deframing: a new mechanism for reading and
analyzing poetry. This theory is derived from the cinematic term décadrage; from
photography, painting and cognitive frames. It aims at unraveling cultural specifics which
affect a (foreign) reader‟s interpretation of a given literary work. Moreover, it introduces
different possible readings and interpretations by spotlighting the less focused scenes /details
in a given work. Deframing necessitates decoding of intertextual and cognitive references,
which helps build an accurate, deeply rooted cultural image without discarding any cultural
implications. On the other hand, it synchronically and diachronically delimits a certain scene
at a definite moment, changing any given interpretation or an expected response. Actually, it
provides the reader with possibilities to revisit a work of art and discover new meanings and
produces different interpretations. The theory will be applied to different poets from William
Shakespeare to E. E. Cummings.
Keywords: Deframing, poetry, literature, painting, photography, cinema, cognitive linguistics
© Published by World Acdemia Org Publication . UK , London
==============================================================================
1. Introduction
The selected poems analysed below show that the theory of deframing can
be applied to poetry and further to literature. The chosen poems had been written
within four hundred years, starting from William Shakespeare and ending with E. E.
Cummings. Each poem highlights different element of the theory; other elements
may be in the background, though. Each of the three bases of the theory, viz.,
photography/ painting, cinema making and cognitive linguistics, provides an
approach to deframe relevant frames. Put together, they form an inseparable whole.
Though frames used by the three bases seem different, they share the same
deframing technique which produces new meanings.
2. Deframing in Photography/Painting
Deframing reminds one of the relation between poetry and painting/
photography, which suggests that a framed meaning is a reflection of the original
meaning in nature. Therefore, to complete this framed meaning, it needs to be
deframed. What the painter observes in nature and vicissitude of people‟s li ves is
both mirrored in his mind and reflected in his paintings, per se. The same can be said
about the poet whose poetry expresses what his eyes behold. M. H. Abrams shows
the relationship between painting, photography and poetry: