The Role of Servant Leadership in Developing an Ethical
Climate in Sport Organizations
Laura J. Burton
University of Connecticut
Jon Welty Peachey
University of Illinois
Janelle E. Wells
University of South Florida
Evaluation of leadership as a necessary component to reform sport could be critical to fostering a more ethical
climate and reducing the frequency and severity of ethical improprieties within this context. However, limited
research has examined the relationship between leadership and ethical climate. Servant leadership, due to its
ethical component and people-centered focus, is a leadership approach that may best support development of
an ethical climate. The purpose of this study was to explore the influence of servant leadership on perceptions
of an ethical climate in intercollegiate athletic departments, with an examination of how trust and perceptions
of organizational justice indirectly influence the relationship between servant leadership and perceptions of an
ethical climate. Findings indicated that servant leadership was directly related to trust in leadership and
perceptions of an ethical climate. Further, both trust in the leader and procedural justice indirectly influenced
the relationship between servant leadership and ethical climate.
Keywords: ethics, intercollegiate athletics, leadership, trust
The sport landscape has been plagued with ethical
improprieties and scandals in recent years. There are
recent examples in U.S. intercollegiate sport (e.g., Penn
State/Jerry Sandusky child sexual abuse scandal,
academic scandals) and U.S. professional sport (e.g.,
National Football League alleged minimization of the
links between concussions and long-term brain injury),
and ethical scandals have also plagued international
sport at the highest level of sport leadership (e.g.,
Federation International de Football Association
bribery scandals, International Association of Athletics
doping scandals). Organizational climates that foster
unethical behavior among leaders, administrators, and
coaches seem to be more the norm than the exception in
sport organizations. In light of these recent ethical
scandals and many others, educators, scholars, and
officials both within and outside of sport management
have called for reform of sport organizations and
those that lead them (Lapchick, 2013; Lopiano &
Gurney, 2014). In essence, scholars are beginning to
call attention to the need for evaluation of leadership as a
necessary component for reform in sport organizations
and in intercollegiate athletics in particular (Burton &
Welty Peachey, 2013; DeSensi, 2014; Sagas & Wigley,
2014). More specifically, leadership is considered criti-
cal to fostering a more ethical climate within sport
organizations (Welty Peachey, Damon, Zhou, &
Burton, 2015).
Current leadership research is moving away from
the more traditional studies of transformational and
transactional leadership toward a stronger emphasis on
a shared and relational perspective, with a focus on the
interaction between a leader and a follower (see Wang,
Waldman, & Zhang, 2014). In addition, work by Welty
Peachey and colleagues (2015) has highlighted the need
to examine different types of leadership within the
context of sport organizations, beyond transformational
and transactional. Servant leadership has gained appeal
as a result of the myriad positive outcomes associated
with this style of leadership, most importantly the unique
Laura J. Burton is with the Department of Educational Leadership,
University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT. Jon Welty Peachey is with the
Department of Recreation, Sport and Tourism, University of Illinois,
Champaign, IL. Janelle E. Well is with the Department of Sport and
Entertainment Management, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL.
Address author correspondence to Laura J. Burton at laura.burton@
uconn.edu.
229
Journal of Sport Management, 2017, 31, 229-240
https://doi.org/10.1123/jsm.2016-0047
© 2017 Human Kinetics, Inc. ARTICLE