International Journal of Applied Engineering Research ISSN 0973-4562 Volume 12, Number 19 (2017) pp. 8681-8688
© Research India Publications. http://www.ripublication.com
8681
Behavior of Reinforcement Concrete Beams Using Steel Strips as a Shear
Reinforcements
Haider K. Ammash
PhD in Structural Engineering, University of Al-Qadisiyah, Iraq.
Orcid ID: 0000-0003-3672-6295
Abstract
An experimental and theoretical study on reinforced concrete
beams using steel strip plates as a shear reinforcement instead
of stirrups bars is presented in this paper. Five specimens with
same dimensions and properties were used in this study. One of
them has regular ties as shear reinforcements and is used as a
reference beam. Other specimens used steel plates as shear
reinforcements with an equivalent area of the regular ties of the
reference beam. Four thicknesses of plates were used, 1mm
2mm, 3mm, and 4mm. The experimental results showed a good
agreement in term of the ultimate load within the range of 99.86
– 113.33 % of the ultimate load of the reference beam. The steel
strips work as a regular tie to control the cracks (number and
width). The analytical result showed that there is a good
agreement between the numerical results and the experimental
results in the term.
Keywords: Crack width, Finite element, Reinforced concrete,
Shear reinforcement, Steel plates.
INTRODUCTION
Reinforced concrete (RC) beams should have acceptable shear
reinforcement to prevent sudden and brittle failure after
formation of the diagonal cracks, and also to keep the crack
width within the acceptable level (Daou & Ghanem, 2003).
Surviving RC beams with shear deficiencies ultimately need
strengthening. Deficiencies may occur due to different factors
such as insufficient shear reinforcement, reduction in steel area
due to corrosion, increased service load, and design defects
(Khalifa, Tumialan, Nanni, & Belarb, 1999). The purpose of
shear reinforcement is to prevent failure in shear, and to
increase beam ductility and subsequently, the likelihood of
sudden failure will be reduced.
The type of shear reinforcements on RC beams has been studied
by many researchers. (Abdul Hamid, 2005) showed
experimentally that the use of additional horizontal and
independent bent- up bars increased the RC beam resistance
against shear forces compared to conventional shear
reinforcement system. (Al-Nasra & Asha, 2013) investigated
four different types of shear reinforcement that can be used in
RC beams; traditional stirrups, welded swimmer bars, bolted
swimmer bars, and u-link bolted swimmer bars. A swimmer bar
is a small inclined bar with its both ends bent horizontally for a
short distance. Their results showed an improvement in shear
strength of RC beams by using swimmer bars in general. (Aziz
& Yaseen, 2013) investigated the effect of type and position of
stirrups of high-strength RC deep beams on the ultimate shear
capacity. Three types of shear reinforcements were used;
vertical stirrups, horizontal stirrups, and inclined stirrups. The
results indicated that ductility and ultimate load capacity were
improved by using vertical with horizontal stirrups and vertical
with inclined stirrups.
(Sinaei, Shariati, Abna, Aghaei, & Shariati, 2012) used
ABAQUS program to model the behavior of reinforced
concrete (RC) beams. In the finite element model, they used
concrete damaged plasticity approach where this model can
help to confirm the theoretical calculations as well as to provide
a valuable supplement to the laboratory investigations of
behavior. For validation, a reinforced concrete beam was
modeled that had been experimentally tested and reported in
previous experimental research. This is followed by a
comparison of the finite element with the experimental results
for the RC beam element. Their study was compared the
numerical results with experimental data for the reinforced
concrete beam subjected to flexural loading. The results
indicate that the displacement, tensile strain for the main
reinforcement, compressive strain for concrete and crack
patterns obtained from the finite element model (FEM) were
well matched with the experimental results.
(Sihua, Ze, & Li, 2015) used the nonlinear analysis of a
reinforced concrete beam was based on the finite element
analysis software ABAQUS. Plasticity model of concrete
damage was employed for simply supported reinforced
concrete beam analysis. Their results of the experimentation
and the ABAQUS analysis were compared in a diagram,
accordingly, reasons of the result difference between the two
methods were discussed, which can be a useful reference for
the further study of the nonlinear analysis of reinforced
concrete.
(Tejaswini & Rama Raju, 2015) presented a study to compare
experimental results with the ABAQUS results. Initially, they
investigated laboratory tests on a beam of 1200 × 200 ×100 mm
of M30 grade concrete for plain, under, balanced, over
reinforced sections. Finite Element Analysis (FEA) had also
been performed using ABAQUS for the model geometry
considered in the experimental study. Their numerical results
from the FEA were compared with the experimental results
which showed that good agreement between the results.