CASE REPORT/CLINICAL TECHNIQUES
C-shaped Canal System in Mandibular Second
Molars: Part I—Anatomical Features
Bing Fan, DDS, MS, PhD, Gary S.P. Cheung, BDS, MDS, MSc, Mingwen Fan, DDS,
James L. Gutmann, DDS, PhD, FACD, FICD, FADI, and Zhuan Bian, DDS, MS, PhD
The purpose of this study was to investigate the
anatomical features of C-shaped root canal system
in mandibular second molars using micro-computed
tomography (CT). Fifty-eight extracted mandibular
second molars with fused roots were collected from
a native Chinese population. The teeth were scanned
into layers of 0.5-mm thickness by CT and mea-
surements were made at eleven levels. The ratio of
the depth of the deepest part of the groove to the
buccal-lingual thickness of the cross-section of the
root was calculated for each tooth. The canal shapes
of the scanned cross-sections were assessed and
classified according to a modified Melton’s method.
Results were subject to the Kruskal-Wallis test. Of
the 58 molars, 54 had a C-shaped canal system with
a mean groove-to-thickness ratio of 47.96%; the four
teeth without a C-shaped canal had a mean ratio of
14.82%. Most orifices (98.1%) were found within 3
mm below the cementoenamel junction. Of teeth
with a C-shape canal system, a majority demon-
strated an orifice with an uninterrupted “C” configu-
ration. Seventeen canals divided in the apical portion,
most of which did so within 2 mm from the apex. The
cross-sectional shape varied drastically along the
length of the canal. Teeth with a high groove-to-
thickness ratio had at least one section with C1, C2,
or C3 configuration. The canal shape in middle and
apical thirds of C-shaped canal systems could not be
predicted on the basis of the shape at the orifice
level. Section 2 of this paper addressed the correla-
tion between the radiographic appearance and these
CT images.
The C-shaped canal system is an anatomical variation mostly seen in
mandibular second molars, although it can also occur in maxillary and
other mandibular molars (1, 2). The main anatomical feature of
C-shaped canals is the presence of a fin or web connecting the
individual root canals—the orifice may appear as a single ribbon-
shaped opening with a 180° arc linking the two main canals (3).
Typically, this canal configuration is found in teeth with fusion of
roots either on its buccal or lingual aspect. In such teeth, the floor of
the pulp chamber is usually situated deeply and may assume an
unusual anatomical appearance. A number of reports have described
different trends in the shape and number of roots and root canals
among different human races (3, 4). The variation appears to be
genetically determined and may be used in tracing the ethnic origin of
the subjects (3). The prevalence of C-shaped canal system in second
mandibular molars has been reported to be 31.5% for the Chinese
population (5), which is much higher than that reported for other
populations (1, 4). When present on one side, a C-shaped canal may
be found in the contralateral tooth in over 70% of individuals (6).
Roots containing a C-shaped canal often have a conical or
square configuration (7, 8). The description regarding these roots
was identified initially in comparative anthropology. Manning (7)
speculated that the failure of the Hertwig’s epithelial root sheath to
fuse on the lingual or buccal root surface was the main cause of a
C-shaped root, which always contains a C-shaped canal. The
C-shaped root may also be formed by coalescence because of
deposition of cementum with time (7).
The C-shaped canal system can assume many variations in its
configuration. Melton and co-workers (9) proposed a classification
of C-shaped canals based on their cross-sectional shape. However,
it has been pointed out that this shape can vary along the length of
the root so that the clinical crown morphology or the appearance of
the canal orifice may not be good predictors of the actual canal
anatomy (10). In Melton’s classification, there has been no clear
description of the difference between categories II and III (i.e. C2
and C3, respectively, in Fig. 1), as well as the clinical significance.
Furthermore, they examined three arbitrary levels of the root and
hence little information is present describing how the canal shape
may change over its length. Cooke and Cox (1) were first to
describe the clinical significance of C-shaped canals, which
present a challenge with respect to their debridement and obtura-
tion. This is especially true when it is uncertain whether a C-shaped
orifice found on the floor of the pulp chamber may continue to the
apical third of the root. Irregular areas in a C-shaped root canal
JOURNAL OF ENDODONTICS Printed in U.S.A.
Copyright © 2004 by The American Association of Endodontists VOL. 30, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2004
899