UNBIASED NOISE ESTIMATION AND DENOISING IN PARALLEL MAGNETIC
RESONANCE IMAGING
Pasquale Borrelli
University of Naples Federico II
Dept. of Advanced Biomedical Sciences
Via Pansini 5, 80131 Naples, Italy
Giuseppe Palma, Marco Comerci, Bruno Alfano
National Research Council of Italy
Inst. of Biostructures and Bioimaging
Via De Amicis 95, 80145 Naples, Italy
ABSTRACT
In magnetic resonance (MR) clinical practice, noise esti-
mation is usually performed on Rayleigh-distributed back-
ground (no signal area) of magnitude images. Although noise
variance in quadrature MR images is considered spatially
independent, parallel MRI (pMRI) techniques as SENSE
or GRAPPA generate spatially varying noise (SVN) distri-
bution. In this scenario noise estimation from background
may produce biased results. To address these limitations we
introduce a novel noise estimation scheme based on local
statistics. Our method turns out to be more accurate than the
other pMRI noise estimation schemes previously described
in the literature. Denoising performances, measured by vi-
sual inspection and peak signal-to-noise ratio (PSNR), of
Non-Local Means denoising filters (NLM) are considerably
improved using SVN-NLM in case of inhomogeneous noise.
Furthermore, SVN-NLM behaves as well as standard NLM
when homogeneous noise was added, thus proving to be a
robust and powerful denoising algorithm for arbitrary MRI
datasets.
Index Terms— Noise estimation, denoising, parallel
MRI, non-local means, Rician noise
1. INTRODUCTION
Noise estimation and, consequently, denoising are crucial
steps in most post-processing tasks of MRI and, particu-
larly, of MR image quantitation. In standard quadrature MRI
(hereafter, sMRI), both real and imaginary images show an
uncorrelated Gaussian noise whose variance is uniform all
over the field of view (FOV). Once the magnitude of the com-
plex images is extracted, the resulting noise follows a Rician
distribution, whose variance can be accurately estimated from
the variance of the voxel values (Rayleigh-distributed) in the
image background (i.e. the no-signal area) [1, 2].
However, as soon as images show a spatially varying
noise distribution, such background-based noise estimation
schemes produce biased results [3, 4].
This work was partially funded by FIRB-MERIT RBNE08E8CZ and
DSB-CNR/MIUR ”Aging” project.
Parallel MRI is an emerged technique that increases the
image acquisition rate by sampling a reduced amount of k-
space data with an array of receiving coils [5, 6]. Generalized
auto-calibrating partially parallel acquisition (GRAPPA) and
sensitivity-encoded (SENSE) MRI are most common image
reconstruction schemes in pMRI. Both reconstruction algo-
rithms share the incorporation of coil-sensitivity profiles into
the image reconstruction process [7]. In GRAPPA algorithm
missing k-space lines are computed before full-image is re-
constructed for each receiver channel [8]. On the other hand,
SENSE algorithm reconstructs complex image for each re-
ceiver channel and then final images are pixel-wise multiplied
by appropriate coil sensitivity mask [9]. The application of
multi-surface coil arrays and reconstruction filter can influ-
ence the statistical distribution of image noise [10]. In this
scenario, variance of background regions will lead to innacu-
rate estimations of the true local noise if a uniform Rayleigh
distribution is erroneously assumed [4].
In the context of denoising algorithms, one of the most
performing and robust denoising approaches is the non-local
means (NLM) filter, introduced in [11]. NLM filter assumes
that the restoring function for a given point is a mean of all
the image values, largely weighted according to the radio-
metric similarity between voxels and only weakly tied to a
spatial proximity criterion. In particular, it has been shown
that NLM filter guarantees the homogeneity of flat zones, pre-
serves edges and fine structures, and transforms white noise
into white noise, thus avoiding the introduction of artifacts
and spurious correlated signal [11, 12]. Although there are
some algorithm variants that take into account spatially vary-
ing noise distribution in image to be filtered [13, 14, 15], at the
best of our knowledge, a robust and accurate noise estimation
in a NLM pipeline has been poorly investigated.
In this paper we present a novel noise estimation based
on NLM filter and local statistics. Our local mask does not
need an a priori knowledge of sensitivity maps, subsampling
factor and geometry factor. Therefore, our noise estimation
technique is successfully applicable to MR images with both
spatially varying and uniform noise distribution.
The plan of the paper is as follows. In §2 we briefly review
2014 IEEE International Conference on Acoustic, Speech and Signal Processing (ICASSP)
978-1-4799-2893-4/14/$31.00 ©2014 IEEE 1239