Research Article OMICS International
Chukwu, J Health Med Informat 2017, 8:3
DOI: 10.4172/2157-7420.1000267
Volume 8 • Issue 3 • 1000267
J Health Med Inform, an open access journal
ISSN: 2157-7420
Journal of
Health & Medical Informatics
J
o
u
r
n
a
l
o
f
H
e
a
lth
&
M
e
d
i
c
a
l
I
n
f
o
r
m
a
t
i
c
s
ISSN: 2157-7420
Keywords: Master Patient Index (MPI); Digital identity; Patient
identiier; ID; mHealth; Client registry; eHealth
Introduction
Health system in Nigeria is weak and faces many daunting
challenges. Poor health indices persist despite huge investment in the last
decade. Routine health [1,2] facility generated data oten cannot be relied
on for planning or for critical decision-making. Health facilities are
increasingly employing digital health tools with limited scalability. his
holds true irrespective of any deinition of the word ‘scale’. Duplicate
patient records have dogged the health system in general and digital
tools in particular. Scalability of these tools has been hampered by lack of
unique patient identity system [3]. Evidence show that the society’s most
vulnerable remain the ones most without any form of Identiiers. hey
are [4] oten inancially excluded, and do not have access to essential
social beneits including health. Sustainable planning and deployment
of other social services like housing, electricity, Internet, and water all
requires citizen demographic information. here have been several cross-
sector attempts to address this identity crisis in Nigeria and globally. his
growing need was aptly highlighted in Sustainable Development Goal
(SDG) target 16.9: “By 2030, provide legal identity for all, including
birth registration” [5]. In addition, properly implemented and managed
patient identiication schemes can signiicantly inluence attainment of
under listed SDG targets amongst others.
1. Social Protection for the most vulnerable (SDG 1.3).
2. Access to economic resource including inance (SDG 1.4).
3. Assistance dealing with Shock and Social disaster (SDG 1.5).
4. Reduce Global MMR (SDG 3.1).
5. Ending preventable deaths of new-borns and under 5 (SDG 3.2).
6. Ending epidemics of AIDs, Malaria, neglected tropical diseases
and combating hepatitis, water-borne and other communicable
diseases (SDG 3.3).
7. Empower women (SDG 5a and SDG 5b).
hese SDG targets afect directly or indirectly the health status of
citizens. Digital identiiers have great potential in big data analytics,
disease surveillance and other intelligent systems. Proper patient
identiication ensures eicient care administration, and movement
of patient information within and between healthcare organizations.
Healthcare delivery involves many stakeholders with varying
responsibilities. At the health facility level, wrong identiication has
been linked to discharge of infants to wrong parents, testing errors,
medication inaccuracies, wrong person procedures, and transfusion
mistakes [6]. Without correctly identifying care beneiciaries,
accountability will remain elusive. At organizational level, Health
insurance claims and care administration continue to be prone to both
errors and manipulation. A functional patient identiication system
helps to ensure signiicant cost savings through waste reduction and
duplicate treatments reduction. here are no accurate information on
the cost and frequency of mismatch errors in health care delivery in
Nigeria. What is clear is that a huge proportion of medical mistakes
still occur in medical practice and most of are linked to this patient
identity crisis. he UK government performed an audit on identity
of patient and care administration in select hospitals, and found
that 34% of patients did not have their identiiers on them [7]. he
research found that even where identiiers exist, provider hand-overs
and related communication challenges introduce chances of patient
misidentiication. his readily points to the scale this can assume in low
and middle-income countries most of which have not even deployed
patient identiier strategy.
Current Status
Functional Identiication systems in Nigeria vary from civic
registration of birth, election, inancial services, to mobile telephony
identity schemes. At the same time, countries have various schemes
for patient speciic identiiers depending on their level of advancement.
*Corresponding author: Emeka Chukwu, M.Sc., Namek Solutions, Garki, Area 11,
Abuja, Nigeria, E-mail: emekac@nameksolutions.com
Received September 20, 2016; Accepted June 20, 2017; Published June 26, 2017
Citation: Chukwu E (2017) The Case for a Unique Digital Patient ID Scheme in
Nigeria. J Health Med Informat 8: 267. doi: 10.4172/2157-7420.1000267
Copyright: © 2017 Chukwu E. This is an open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and
source are credited.
Abstract
Uniquely identifying patients in the health system has eluded the Nigerian health sector players. Digital health tools are being
deployed to address different challenges in the Nigerian health system with little showing any sign of scale. Despite global interest in
digital identity system and its potential to improve health outcome, little progress has been registered in Nigeria. Nigeria has a convoluted
patient identity system at the time of writing with patient identity local to health facility and sometimes department. Functional Identiication
systems like civic registration of birth, election, and inancial services, to mobile telephony identity schemes are variously in place in
Nigeria. These functional identity systems were reviewed for size of enrolees, data quality, and possibility of use as health functional
identity system. Health sector stakeholders have two options to address the identity crisis. Either to adopt one of the existing functional
identity systems or a combination of them or to setup a Master Patient Index (MPI) based client registry for the health system. This work
having reviewed the factors necessary to adopt a functional identity system, recommends deployment of State based client registries as
a way of addressing this challenge. The recommended framework of action is to develop a policy and strategy to guide implementation,
implement as appropriate at different levels and then monitor while improving as appropriate. A good functional identity system will take
into consideration necessary behaviour changes, staff workload, State autonomy, political interest, patient privacy, technology and return
on investment concerns including total cost of ownership even for open source technology solutions.
The Case for a Unique Digital Patient ID Scheme in Nigeria
Emeka Chukwu*
Namek Solutions, Area 11, Abuja, Nigeria