S.K. Das et al., Man and Environment XLII (2): 11-20 [2017].
© Indian Society for Prehistoric and Quaternary Studies
Provenance Study of Ancient Potteries from West Bengal and Tamil Nadu:
Application of Major Element Oxides and Trace Element Geochemistry
Supriyo Kumar Das
1
, Santanu Ghosh
1
, Kaushik Gangopadhyay
2
, Subhendu Ghosh
3
and Manoshi Hazra
1
1. Department of Geology, Presidency University, College Street 86/1, Kolkata 700073
2. Department of Archaeology, University of Calcutta, 1 Reformatory Street, Kolkata 700027
3. Geological Survey of India, Central Chemical Laboratory, 15 A & B Kyd Street, Kolkata 700016
E-mail: k.gongo@gmail.com
Abstract
Geochemical study of pottery provides useful information on the source of the raw materials (clay)
of ancient vessels. However, published geochemical data on potteries from eastern coastal region of
India is limited. Moreover, there are debates on the provenance of certain categories of fine ware,
including the ‘Rouletted ware’, found in eastern coastal India. The uncertainty about the provenance
of the potteries is primarily due to the fact that geochemical/geological sources of clay used for
manufacturing of potteries has till now never been taken into account. To address the issue, major
element oxides and trace elements in potsherds collected from surface context at three sites situated
along the east coast of India namely Chandraketugarh and Tamluk in West Bengal, and Arikamedu
in Tamil Nadu have been analysed. Samples from each sherd was prepared as a homogenised
powder, and major element oxides and trace elements was analysed using wave length dispersive
X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy (WD-XRF). Further, the study drew on already published major
element oxide data of ancient potteries and sediments from Tamil Nadu and the Ganga Plains to
identify the source of clay. The result indicates that the potteries were made of clay derived from
the weathering of felsic to intermediate rocks, which are abundant in Tamil Nadu and Puducherry,
but absent in West Bengal. The uniform geochemical character of the potteries collected from the
geographically separated sites further implies that the potteries were manufactured using a single
type of clay. It is likely that the potteries were manufactured at or close to the archaeological site in
Arikamedu, and exported to the site in lower West Bengal such as Tamluk and Chandraketugarh.
Introduction
Pottery, one of the main artefacts is studied by
archaeologists to locate its provenance, and thereby
understand the trading and/or exchange systems and
networks. Pottery is manufactured using clay, which is
primarily composed of hydrous aluminium phyllosilicates
with variable amount of iron (Fe), magnesium (Mg),
sodium (Na), and potassium (K), and is produced from the
weathering of aluminosilicate rocks (Chandrasekaran et al.
2013: 29-40). Hence, it is hypothesised that the
geochemistry of the clay used for manufacturing the pottery
can be correlated with the geochemistry of the source rock
of the clay. Thus application of geochemical studies is a
necessary prerequisite, as provenance analysis of pottery
would help derive useful information on the source of the
raw materials (clay) of the ancient vessels (Ramos et al.
2002a: 893-900, b: 689-700; Laviano et al. 2006: 49-62;
Dias and Prudêncio 2008; Prudêncio et al. 2009: 873-883).
Received: 27-12-2016
Revised: 29-04-2017
Accepted: 28-05-2017
Early historic fine wares, dated from c. 4th-3rd BCE to 3rd
centuries CE, are found from several archaeological sites in
eastern India, south-eastern coastal India, Sri Lanka and
Bangladesh (Begley 1983: 461-81, 1988:427-40; Salles and
Allios 2005: 27-34; Ford et al. 2005: 909-920; Schenk 2006:
123-53; Magee 2010:1043-1054). These wares have
homogenous fine grey core and are generally thin to medium
in section. The surface of the fine wares is found either slipped
or polished with a grey surface and a black slip or with blotchy
red and grey surface. The rouletted ware (henceforth referred
as RW) is one of the varieties of fine ware included in Begley’s
report of excavations (Begley 1996) at Arikamedu in Tamil
Nadu, India (Fig.
1). Later, Salles and Allios reviewed her conclusions (Salles
and Allios 2005: 27-34). The RW is a more carefully potted
ware in monochrome (grey and black) or bichrome (black-
and-red, grey and black). The most common form of RW
excavated at Arikamedu is large dish (approximately 28 cm
diameter) with internal concentric circle where the surface