Frumkin et al.
1636 Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 129, no. 11/12
ABSTRACT
We analyzed maze caves and the associated
hydrogeology in the northern Negev–Judean
Desert in Israel to provide insight on fluid
migration and porosity development, with
relevance to groundwater and petroleum res-
ervoirs on the Arabian Platform flanks. The
caves occur specifically in the arid region
of the southern Levant, with no equivalent
in the moister climate areas further to the
north. The karstified bedrock consists of Up-
per Cretaceous epicontinental carbonates.
Caves were formed mainly above deep faults
associated with the Syrian arc fold system.
Hypogenic flow is shown to have formed the
maze caves particularly under the confine-
ment of thick chalk and marl cap rock. Spe-
leogenesis occurred during the Oligocene–
early Miocene when the Afro-Arabian dome
was rising and became erosionally truncated.
Calcite deposits depleted in
18
O point to a
connection between the caves and recharge
over far-field Nubian Sandstone outcrops,
north of the Precambrian basement outcrops
on the eastern side of the Red Sea. During
the early–middle Miocene, the Dead Sea rift
began dissecting the region, forming a deep
endorheic depression at the eastern margin
of the study area and disconnecting the far-
field groundwater flow. This was followed by
subsiding groundwater levels and associated
dewatering of the caves. Fault escarpments
and canyon downcutting then dissected the
caves, forming the present entrances. The
caves are currently mostly dry, with scarce
speleothem occurrences. Gypsum crusts with
δ
34
S
SO
4
values lower than other sulfate depos-
its point to bacterial sulfur reduction, hydro-
gen sulfide, and sulfuric acid being involved
in the speleogenesis.
GSA Bulletin; November/December 2017; v. 129; no. 11/12; p. 1636–1659; https://doi.org/10.1130/B31694.1; 13 figures; 1 table; published online 6 July 2017.
†
amos.frumkin@mail.huji.ac.il
Hypogenic karst at the Arabian platform margins:
Implications for far-field groundwater systems
Amos Frumkin
†
, Boaz Langford, Sorin Lisker, and Alon Amrani
Institute of Earth Sciences, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem 91904, Israel
INTRODUCTION
Caves are used here as indicators to re-
construct the paleogeography and evolution
of the northwestern margins of the Arabian
platform (Fig. 1) during the mid-Tertiary, and
to shed light on the relationships among lime-
stone porosity, regional groundwater flow,
and tectonic structure.
Major erosional events, which create trunca-
tion surfaces and depositional unconformities,
form important parts of the geological record.
However, these events still remain enigmatic
due to the lack of chronological constraints
(Osborne, 2013; Polyak and Hill, 2013). In the
southern Levant, a regional truncation surface
(Picard, 1943; Avni et al., 2012) represents
such an event where the related formation pro-
cesses are relatively unknown. This erosional
surface, truncating carbonate strata, is coupled
with hitherto undocumented ancient caves. We
investigated the karstic caves to elucidate the de-
velopment of limestone macroporosity and sub-
surface processes associated with the regional
truncation surface.
Unlike most other karst regions, the Negev
and Judean Deserts have been mostly under arid
conditions for millions of years (Amit et al.,
2006, 2011; Vaks et al., 2013; Matmon et al.,
2014). Present karst denudation rates of flat-lying
bedrock outcrops along interfluves range from
∼20 mm k.y.
-1
in the Mediterranean–semiarid
border zone to 1–3 mm k.y.
-1
in the hyperarid
zone at the Dead Sea Escarpment (Ryb et al.,
2014). This indicates good preservation of the
previous truncation surface at the interfluves,
with only a few tens of meters of denudation
since regional truncation. The denudation rarely
affects the caves, which are mostly preserved
under a thick cap rock.
Unlike “common” epigenic caves (Dreybrodt
et al., 2005; Ford and Williams, 2007; Palmer,
2007; Slabe and Prelovšek, 2013), hypogenic
caves are generated by upwelling water in which
reactivity has been enhanced deep beneath the
surface, independent of surface or soil CO
2
or
other near-surface acid sources (Klimchouk,
2007, 2013; Audra and Palmer, 2015). Such
caves may allow a reconstruction of landscape
evolution and paleohydrogeology over long pe-
riods and large basins (Polyak and Hill, 2013;
Piccini et al., 2015). To achieve this, insight into
regional cave characteristics and the associated
hydrogeology is required (Klimchouk, 2015).
Hypogenic speleogenesis has been suggested as
a process that formed a small cave in the Negev
(Issar and Gross, 1969).
Following a major cave survey (Langford
and Frumkin, 2013; Frumkin, 2015), the desert
areas of southeastern Israel, namely, the Negev
and Judean Deserts (Fig. 1), stand out as the
most important hypogenic cave province in the
southern Levant (including Israel, Jordan, Syria,
and Lebanon). Fewer similar caves are known
in the much larger nearby regions (e.g., Frumkin
and Gvirtzman, 2006; Kempe et al., 2006).
Cave formation requires actively circulat-
ing groundwater. However, the Negev-Judean
Deserts are the driest regions in the southern
Levant; therefore, the paleogeographic condi-
tions that gave rise to the abundance of caves
should be understood. The long-term aridity of
the region has prevented overprinting of hypo-
genic caves by epigenic processes, thus allow-
ing easier identification and understanding of
hypogenic features.
Geological Background
Located on the leeward flank of the Judean
Mountains (Fig. 1), the Judean Desert is a rain-
shadow desert, while the Negev is a part of the
Saharan-Arabian Desert belt. The climate varies
between semiarid to hyperarid, with cool win-
ters and hot dry summers. Mean annual precipi-
tation varies from 400 mm in the northwestern
semiarid zone to 30 mm at the southern Negev.
Annual potential evapotranspiration varies from
1600 mm in the northwest to 2600 mm on the
south (Shachar, 2011). Over 80% of the annual
For permission to copy, contact editing@geosociety.org
© 2017 Geological Society of America