Alkylation Kinetics of Isobutane by C4 Olefins Using Sulfuric Acid as
Catalyst
Weizhen Sun, Yi Shi, Jie Chen, Zhenhao Xi, and Ling Zhao*
State-Key Laboratory of Chemical Engineering, East China University of Science and Technology, Shanghai 200237, China
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: The alkylation kinetics of isobutane with butene using sulfuric acid as catalyst was investigated by batch
experiments in the conditions of industrial interest. More than 16 alkylates were identified and quantified by GC-MS. On the
basis of the classic carbonium ion mechanism, the kinetic model was established, which can predict the concentration change of
three groups of key alkylates including trimethylpentanes (TMPs), undesirable dimethylhexanes (DMHs), and heavy ends
(HEs). The agreement between experimental and model calculated data was quite satisfactory. The rate constants were found to
be constant with the varied temperatures (276.2 to 285.2 K) except those accounting for the addition of H
+
to isobutene and its
reversible reaction. An anti-Arrhenius behavior was observed for the addition reaction of H
+
to isobutene, in which the
corresponding rate constant falls with the increasing temperatures. The kinetic model was confirmed by the simulation of the
industrial alkylation reactor. Hopefully, the kinetic model developed in this work will be useful to the design and optimization of
novel alkylation reactors.
1. INTRODUCTION
In early 1990s, the USA refiners had to start changing their
strategy on gasoline composition to meet the mandatory CAA
(Clean Air Act) specifications.
1
Since that time, gasoline was
forced to move in a more environmentally friendly direction,
such as reducing volatility, limitations in the aromatic content,
increased amount of oxygenates, reduction of olefins and sulfur,
and elimination of lead. As a desirable blending component,
without olefins or aromatics, alkylate exclusively contains
isoalkanes with high octane number. Since its commercial
production in the last century, alkylate had been the most ideal
blending component for a typical refinery gasoline pool. Nearly
70% of the world’s alkylate production is from North America,
and over 20% is produced from Europe.
2
It was believed that
alkylate will continue to be a desirable blending component as
long as cars are operated on high octane gasoline.
3
The alkylation reaction producing alkylates combines
isobutane with light C3-C5 olefins in the presence of a strong
acid catalyst. Currently, the only processes of commercial
importance use either sulfuric or hydrofluoric acid as catalysts.
4
Although the number of established alkylation units using
sulfuric acid is almost as much as that using hydrofluoric acid,
more new alkylation plants built worldwide chose sulfuric acid
as catalyst in the recent past years.
5
One of the reasons is that
hydrofluoric acid is a highly toxic liquid, and released into the
atmosphere, it forms aerosol, which drifts downwind for several
kilometers.
6
Actually, both acids suffer from certain drawbacks,
but it is not the intent of this work to review in detail the pros
and cons of sulfuric acid versus hydrofluoric acid but to address
the alkylation kinetics using sulfuric acid as a catalyst.
It is well-known that the study on reaction kinetics is of
fundamental importance not only to the design and
optimization of a ripe chemical reactor but also to the
development of a novel one. Also, it is helpful in understanding
the reaction mechanism. As to the alkylation mechanism of
isobutane with olefins, much classical literature had been
published,
7-11
in which the formation pathway of the majority
of key components and intermediates in alkylate were well
formulated although different publications would have different
descriptions regarding some specific steps. However, to the best
of our knowledge, there was little literature focusing on the
alkylation kinetics of isobutane with butene in sulfuric acid to
address the formation of several key alkylates such as
trimethylpentanes (TMPs), dimethylhexanes (DMHs), and
heavy ends (HEs). Using uniform hydrocarbon drops and short
contact time, the sulfuric acid catalyzed reaction of isobutane
with 1-butene, as well as the oligomerization of 1-butene, was
investigated, in which only two key reactions were consid-
ered,
12
but other important reaction steps in view of the
presence of several dozen isoparaffins in commercial produced
alkylates are far from being understood.
13
The two-step process
for the alkylation of isobutane with C4 olefins was investigated,
but the rate constants were not given.
10
In this work, the alkylation kinetics of isobutane with butene
using sulfuric acid as catalyst was measured under the condition
of industrial interest. The kinetic model was established on the
basis of the carbonium ion mechanism, in which three families
of key isoparaffins were considered including TMPs, DMHs,
and HEs.
2. EXPERIMENTAL SECTION
The experiments were carried out in a batch setup with a glass
reactor with the volume of 1 L. To keep isobutane and olefin in
Special Issue: NASCRE 3
Received: February 4, 2013
Revised: April 2, 2013
Accepted: April 3, 2013
Published: April 3, 2013
Article
pubs.acs.org/IECR
© 2013 American Chemical Society 15262 dx.doi.org/10.1021/ie400415p | Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2013, 52, 15262-15269