Decisive Role of Hydrophobicity on the Effect of Alkylammonium
Chlorides on Protein Stability: A Terahertz Spectroscopic Finding
Debasish Das Mahanta, Nirnay Samanta, and Rajib Kumar Mitra*
Chemical, Biological and Macromolecular Sciences, S. N. Bose National Centre for Basic Sciences Block-JD, Sector-III, Salt Lake,
Kolkata, 700106, India
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Many biologically important processes involve a
subtle interplay between Columbic and hydrophobic interactions
among molecular groups with water. A comprehensive under-
standing of such processes, specially while occurring simultaneously
in the same molecule is of practical importance. In this
contribution, we report the ultrafast (subpicosecond to pico-
second) collective hydrogen bond dynamics of water in the
extended hydration layers in a series of alkylammonium chloride
salts using THz time domain spectroscopic (TTDS) technique
(0.3-1.6 THz (10-55 cm
-1
)). We found the THz absorption
coefficient (α) of the salt solutions systematically vary with the salt
type. We obtain the hydrogen bond relaxation dynamics by fitting
the frequency dependent dielectric constants in a multiple Debye dielectric relaxation model. We found these salts to transform
from being a water “structure breaker” to “structure maker” with increasing carbon content. We also investigate their effect on a
model protein “bovine serum albumin” and found a systematic trend toward disrupting the protein secondary structure. The
associated changes in the protein hydration in the presence of these salts have also been investigated using TTDS.
■
INTRODUCTION
Nonpolar hydrophobic molecules in water are believed to
increase disorder due to their inability to form a H-bond with
the polar water molecules.
1
However, they can also enhance the
ordering in their surrounding water network.
2
The notion of
hydrophobic hydration, still a popular topic of research, is
highly specific on the solute type and dimension. Either small
hydrophobic solutes get arrested within the polyhedral cage
formed by the under- or uncoordinated water molecules with
dangling O-H bonds
2,3
or the solutes as well as the solvent
separately aggregate to form clusters
4
with an enhanced H-
bond network. Larger solutes can even disrupt the tetrahedral
network of water. In both cases, there exist defects in the water
H-bonded network,
3
which is the key driving factor that
governs most of the physicochemical and biological pro-
cesses.
5-9
Likewise, ion-water interaction also plays important
role in biology and chemistry.
10,11
Electrolytes perturb the H-
bonded structure in liquid water, thereby either strengthen-
ing
12,13
or rupturing the water network,
12,14
the extent being
highly ion specific in nature.
15-17
Bakker et al. have shown that
hydration dynamics of ions is cooperative in nature and
depends on the hydration of the counterions also.
18
THz
spectroscopic investigation by Havenith et al.
19,20
established a
strong correlation between hydration dynamics and the
“rattling” motion of metal ions. A direct correlation between
H-bonding and water structure making/breaking ability of ions
is highly debatable. Strongly hydrated ions tend to align the
static dipoles of their surrounding water molecules. Such effect
could be extended beyond the second or third solvation shell of
the ions.
12,21
Structural information on ion hydration has so far
been realized using neutron and X-ray diffraction,
22
X-ray
absorption spectroscopy,
23
IR and Raman spectroscopy
24
while
the corresponding dynamics has been revealed using various
techniques including fs IR pump-probe spectroscopy,
18,25
broadband dielectric spectroscopy,
26,27
2D IR vibrational echo
experiments,
28,29
optical Kerr rotation spectroscopy
30
vibra-
tional sum frequency generation spectroscopy
31,32
and various
computer simulation studies.
13,33,34
Instead of understanding electrostatic and hydrophobic
interactions individually, it is of practical importance to study
them while operating simultaneously. In this regard, cations
consisting of water repelling moieties have recently attracted
attention among researchers owing to their unique hydration
behavior.
32, 35-39
Alkylammonium halides are the most
extensively studied salts that possess the rare combination of
ionic and hydrophobic characters in the same molecule, with a
tunable hydrophobicity. Such molecules contain short chain
alkanes and unlike amphiphilic molecules do not usually
aggregate at moderate concentrations.
36
There have been
several studies about the physical nature of water around these
molecules using various experimental and simulation techni-
ques.
37,40-44
These studies have questioned the popular belief
Received: May 1, 2017
Revised: July 24, 2017
Published: July 25, 2017
Article
pubs.acs.org/JPCB
© XXXX American Chemical Society A DOI: 10.1021/acs.jpcb.7b04088
J. Phys. Chem. B XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX