Page 1 of7
Locating Short-Circuit Faults in Underground Networks
J. Zhou, B. Ayhan, and C. Kwan
Signal Processing, Inc.
9700 Great Seneca Highway
Rockville, MD 20850, USA
chiman.kwan@signalpro.net
Abstract -- In power distribution networks, impedance short
circuit faults are hard to detect in their incipient stage, as the
fault currents may not be large enough to trip circuit breakers.
In this paper, we summarize our research activities in short
circuit fault localization in underground power distribution
networks. First, a simulation testbed was built. It can emulate
power distribution networks with both bolted and impedance
faults. Different impedances can be added to different branches.
Power injection points, load nodes, and short-circuit fault
locations can all be adjusted by users. Second, a hardware
testbed corresponding to the simulation testbed was fabricated.
Third, two novel fault localization algorithms (fault signature
matching and sparisity recovery) were implemented. Results
obtained from the simulation and hardware testbeds have
excellent agreement. Our fault localization algorithms are
validated by extensive numerical and experimental data. It is
observed that, standard voltage measurements at a small
number of pre-selected nodes are suicient to localize the faults
precisely; and hence, our fault localization scheme is of low cost.
In addition, since our algorithms require only simple matrix
calculations, localization within a few cycles « 50ms) is
achievable.
Indx Terms-- short-circuit, fault localization, sparsity
recovery, impedance fault.
I. NOMENCLATURE
DTCR - Dynamic Thermal Capacity Rating
EPRI - Electric Power Research Institute
ERCOT - Electric Reliability Council of Texas
NPR: Network Protector Relays
SCADA - Supervisory Control And Data Acquisition
II. INTRODUCTION
How to maintain the integrity of underground power
distribution networks is an important and challenging topic
for power industry. As an example, Con Edison experiences
more than 1600 failures on its distribution feeders and 1000
arcing faults on its secondary distribution system each year
[1], resulting in serious consequences like cable bunout,
manhole explosions, and service interruption. Accurate, low
cost, and automated systems to detect and localize faults in
underground power distribution networks have been sought
ater for years; but, their developments are still at early stage.
High complexity of underground power networks constitutes
the primary challenge to arive at eicient fault detection
schemes. Fig. 1 shows a typical underground power network
where high voltage power transmission lines are connected to
O. D. Limaye, M. Lu, and W. Lee
University of Texas at Arlington
Arlington, TX 76019, USA
low voltage underground power mesh networks via
transformers and network protector relays. Three
complications displayed in Fig. 1 make fault localization in
power network dificult. First, the network is fed by power
transmission lines via multiple injection points. Hence it is
virtually impossible to track the transmission lines to pinpoint
the faults. Second, although the faults do have tremendous
impacts to their neighborhoods, typically they do not bring
up drastic disturbances to the overall behavior of the
network, especially at their incipient stages. Third, the faults'
signatures are usually attenuated by the large number of loads
in the network. In recent years, temperature sensors have
been proposed to monitor cable faults [2] and power
distribution equipment [5]. For example, Electric Power
Research Institute (EPRI) used to execute a program named
"Dynamic Thermal Capacity Rating (DTCR)." Several utility
companies implemented similar pilot programs as well; for
instance, Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT)
initiated a SCADA program in 2007. A major drawback
pertinent to using temperature sensors for fault detection is
the relatively long lag time; especially, the temperature
sensors are very slow [4] to react to impedance faults and low
intensity arcing faults [5]. Typical response time is around 1
second [4]. In addition, temperature sensors have to reside in
the proximity of the fault locations to achieve suficient
sensitivity. Embedding these temperature sensors for fault
inspection in large-scale underground networks would
require a lot of sensors densely distributed throughout the
entire network, which is logistically demanding and cost
prohibiting. There are also attempts to apply iber optic
sensors for the purpose of cable monitoring [3]. However
several years ago, an investigation conducted by Con Edison
concluded iber optic sensors an ineffective solution, because
of cost and effectiveness (probability of detection and false
alarm rates) [7].
protector relays
Fig. 1. A typical underground power transmission network.
978-1-4244-9500-9/11/$26.00 © 2011 IEEE