Road Test Experiments and Statistical Analysis for
Real-Time Monitoring of Road Surface Conditions
Abstract— Road information services (RIS) is a major
component of the information and communication technologies
with the main purpose of RIS-based systems is to monitor road
health conditions, weather information and traffic congestion.
Considering the road conditions, there are various kinds of road
surface types and anomalies with lack of efficient analysis of their
behavior on the vehicle sensor measurements. Consequently, there
are difficulties in detecting and categorizing the different road
types and anomalies. This paper demonstrates road test results for
the measurements of inertial sensors mounted in land vehicles
while monitoring various road surface types and anomalies. In
addition, a wavelet-based feature extraction together with
statistical approach for the road types and anomalies are explored
in this study. Two road test experiments on two different vehicles
performed in Kingston, ON, Canada together with in-depth
analysis are discussed in this paper.
Keywords—Road information services; vehicular resources;
intra-vehicle sensing; Road anomalies; automotive inertial sensors;
statistical analysis; wavelet analysis;
I. INTRODUCTION
Recently, intelligent transportation systems (ITS) has
received a significant amount of interest from the information
and communication technologies (ICT) community, and at the
industrial and academic level as well. According to a study
provided by P&S market research in 2014, it was expected that
the Global ITS market to increase from $18M to reach $38M in
2020, with a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 13.1%
between 2015 and 2020 [1]. The evolution of computers,
sensors, control, communications and electronics devices can
lead to ITS solutions that save lives, time, money, energy, and
the environment. Current computers and communication
systems technologies are being developed in a manner to
improve transportation around the world. The integration of
such systems provides several forms of intelligent links between
travelers, vehicles, and infrastructures to eliminate the
challenges in transportation [2].
Next generation ITS systems, specifically those involved in
road traffic monitoring, will be required to provide reports of
traffic congestion, road conditions, and driver behavior. Road
surface anomalies, as one of the road conditions indicators,
contribute to increased risk of traffic accidents, reduced driver
comfort and increased wear of vehicles. As a notable evidence
of the anomalies effect, traffic accidents resulted from weather
or road conditions are 33% of 2M+ accidents reported by
Transport Canada between 2001 and 2011 [3]. Moreover,
according to the American Automobile Association (AAA), two
thirds of U.S drivers are worried of road surface anomalies, with
approximately $3 billion a year in car repairs [4].
There are some attempts for monitoring road surface
conditions but most of them were depending on 3
rd
party sensing
infrastructure and with limitation in information variety.
Furthermore, road surface conditions monitored by authorities
rely on special instrumentation integrated with specific
simulation software or even reported manually [5]. Some
research work has addressed (RIS) and road surface anomalies.
In [6] a system was developed to monitor braking events and
pump detections using accelerometers, GPS and audio sensors
of a smart phone. For the event localization, they relied on GSM
and GPS. In addition, a system proposed in [7] used
accelerometers of smart phone to classify and detect various
pothole types with a GPS used for localization. RoADS, a
system in [8] used smartphone’s accelerometer, gyroscope and
GPS sensors to classify road anomalies into three categories
named severe, mild and span. Each category contained events
that share similar behavior over the collected data. A back-end
server in [9] was used to categorize anomalies in three
categories. Data collected by vehicle mounted with
accelerometer was sent to the back-end server whenever an
internet-based connection is available.
Most of the available road surface monitoring systems lack
full insight into the required aspects that formulate robust
monitoring of anomalies. These systems presented few types of
anomalies [6] or just focused in details of one type of anomalies
[7]. In addition, some solutions that classify road anomalies lack
adequate geo-referencing of the detected events as they rely only
on GPS, which may introduce large localizing errors especially
at high vehicle speed or in urban canyons [8, 10]. Generally, in
urban areas and downtown cores, the localization accuracy
greatly deteriorates due to GPS satellite signal blockage and
multipath [11, 12].
Amr S. El-Wakeel
*
, Abdalla Osman
†
, Aboelmagd Noureldin
*†‡
and Hossam S. Hassanein
‡†
*
Electrical and Computer Eng. Dept., Queen’s University, Kingston, ON, Canada, K7L 3N6
{amr.elwakeel, nourelda} @queensu.ca
†
Electrical and Computer Eng. Dept., Royal Military College of Canada, Kingston, ON, Canada, K7K 7B4
{Abdalla.Osman, Aboelmagd.Noureldin} @rmc.ca
‡
School of Computing, Queen’s University, Kingston, ON, Canada, K7L 3N6
Hossam@cs.queensu.ca
978-1-5090-5019-2/17/$31.00 ©2017 IEEE