Abstract—The safety and commercial benefits of Intelligent
Transportation System (ITS) raised interests towards
inter-vehicle networking technologies such as Vehicular Ad-hoc
Network (VANET). Being an approved standard for wireless
access in vehicular environments, IEEE 802.11p attracts a lot of
research attentions, especially on its broadcasting performance.
However, most of the previous network performance models paid
little attention to vehicle distribution, or simply assumed
homogeneous car distribution. It is obvious that vehicles are
distributed non-homogeneously along a road segment due to
traffic controls and speed limits at different portions of the road.
In light of the inadequacy, we present in this paper an original
methodology to study the performance of 802.11p VANETs with
practical vehicle distribution in urban environment. An
empirically verified stochastic traffic model is adopted, which
incorporates the effect of urban settings (such as traffic lights) on
car distribution and generates practical car density profiles.
Based on the knowledge of car density at each location from the
traffic model, the 802.11p broadcasting model is developed and a
new metric, Broadcasting Performance Index (BPI), is introduced
to better characterize the broadcasting performance and packet
collision probability in VANETs. Furthermore, the analytical
closed form for BPI is derived and its accuracy is confirmed with
extensive simulation. In general, our results demonstrate the
applicability of the proposed methodology on modeling protocol
performance, and shed insights into the performance analysis of
other communication protocols and network configurations in
urban vehicular networks.
Index Terms— Vehicular Ad-hoc Network (VANET), IEEE
802.11p, Stochastic Traffic Model, Markov Chain, Broadcasting
Performance Index (BPI).
I. INTRODUCTION
With the growing number of cars on road, inter-vehicle
networking technologies such as VANET attracted a lot of
research effort to improve transportation safety. For example,
rear-end collisions can be largely avoided if the braking car can
send a warning message to the following cars. Besides,
non-safety-related communication applications, such as
Internet access and commercial advertising can also be enabled
by VANET. In the US, a 75 MHz Dedicated Short Range
Communication (DSRC) band was allocated for vehicular
communications in 1999 [1]. The band is divided into seven 10
MHz channels. These include a control channel (CCH) for
critical safety data exchange and six service channels (SCH) for
non-safety-related data communication. To exploit the DSRC
band, the original IEEE 802.11 or WiFi standard was enhanced
to support inter-vehicle communications. For instance, the
IEEE 802.11p amendment was published in July 2010 [2]. For
the bottom networking layers, the standard adopts the PHY
layer of 802.11a, and the MAC layer of 802.11e to
accommodate the needs of vehicular communication.
IEEE 802.11p uses CSMA/CA as the medium access
method. In this method, time is divided into slots of 16 ρs and
every node maintains a contention counter loaded with random
integer picked between 0 and W
SS
. During a busy slot, the
contention counter is frozen, but once the channel is sensed idle
for consecutive periods or Arbitration Inter-frame Spaces
(AIFS), the contention counter decreases by one for each
passing idle slot. When the counter reaches zero, the packet is
sent out. If two nodes start transmission in the same time slot or
the transmission is interrupted by a hidden node, the
transmission is failed, and the package is scheduled for
retransmission with doubled contention window [0, 2W
SS
],
which is the well-known exponential backoff process.
Retransmission upon collisions keeps occurring until the upper
limit of the contention window reaches a predefined maximum
value CW
max
.
IEEE 802.11p also implements various Quality of Service
(QoS) classes for traffic with different priorities by setting
different values of W
SS
and AIFS (see Table 1). Therefore,
every node maintains four queues, and each of them buffers a
class of data. The queues are prioritized according to the
importance of the data class. According to Table 1 again, the
safety data queue in Access Class 3 (AC3) has the highest
priority in contention. Lastly, the 802.11p standard requires
each node to stay in the CCH and SCH alternatively for 50 ms
in a switching period of length t
p
= 100 ms [3, 4] for ensuring
service data exchange as well as safety data propagation. For
further details of the IEEE 802.11p standard, the reader is
referred to [1 – 4].
Table 1. Contention parameters for different access classes in 802.11p.
AC Data Class CWmin CWmax AIFS
3 Video & Safety related 3 7 2
2 Voice 3 7 3
1 Best Effort 7 15 6
0 Background Traffic 15 1023 9
A data type of particular interest in inter-vehicle
communications is the safety information broadcast. Cars
equipped with GPS can inform their neighbors of their
locations, velocity, acceleration and any emergency warnings
through broadcasting. These safety information packets called
the “heartbeat” of the vehicular network are of constant length
(500 bytes), and are generated periodically (at a rate of 10 Hz).
Because of its importance, heartbeat is broadcasted on the CCH
with the highest priority. Hence, the broadcasting performance
is a key evaluation parameter for VANET.
However, the broadcasting node has no means to identify a
collision, since no ACK packet will be sent by the receivers in
broadcasting. Therefore, developing models for new
broadcasting standards and identifying the optimal
A Stochastic Traffic Modeling Approach for 802.11p
VANET Broadcasting Performance Evaluation
Harry J. F. Qiu, Ivan Wang-Hei Ho, Chi K. Tse
Department of Electronic and Information Engineering, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University
07835614d@connect.polyu.hk, {ivanwh.ho, encktse}@polyu.edu.hk
2012 IEEE 23rd International Symposium on Personal, Indoor and Mobile Radio Communications - (PIMRC)
978-1-4673-2569-1/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE 1077