The Cecily Effect: A Pilot Study
Martin Hinton
Abstract During earlier trials investigating mimicry ability and its effect on second
language pronunciation, I discovered that while most subjects showed similar levels
of ability across trials with different input languages, some did significantly better
on one language than others. An examination of the individuals affected suggested
that they may have been influenced by the perceived degree of attractiveness of the
input language. This possible phenomenon I refer to as the Cecily Effect, after the
Oscar Wilde character who felt speaking German made her look plain. This paper
discusses the importance of mimicry in general and the role of perception of the
target language in ultimate performance, as well as describing the original trials
referred to above. It goes on to give a detailed account of a pilot study conducted on
ten female subjects using three input languages. Subjects rated a sample of each
language for attractiveness, completed a mimicry exercise in each language and
filled out a personality questionnaire as well as providing a sample of English
pronunciation. Scores in the mimicry exercise could then be compared both with
each other and with the responses given to the survey questions, as well as the level
of ability in English pronunciation. Although the number of participants was too
small to draw any real conclusion from the attempt to link attitudinal factors with
mimicry ability, the results do seem to support the claims that mimicry ability does
influence eventual foreign language pronunciation, and that it may be influenced
both by affective and personality factors.
Keywords Mimicry
Á
Aptitude
Á
Affect
Á
Pronunciation
Á
The Cecily Effect
M. Hinton (&)
University of Łódź, Łódź, Poland
e-mail: mdhinton@tlen.pl
© Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2015
E. Piechurska-Kuciel and M. Szyszka (eds.), The Ecosystem of the Foreign
Language Learner, Second Language Learning and Teaching,
DOI 10.1007/978-3-319-14334-7_2
19