Illustration-Inspired Visualization of Blood Flow Dynamics
Peter Coppin, John Harvey
Perceptual Artifacts Lab
OCAD University
Toronto, Canada
pcoppin@faculty.ocadu.ca, jroharvey@icloud.com
Kristian Valen-Sendstad, Dolores Steinman,
David Steinman
Biomedical Simulation Laboratory
University of Toronto
Toronto, Canada
{kvs,dolores,steinman}@mie.utoronto.ca
Abstract— Image-based computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is
a central tool in the evaluation of hemodynamic factors in cardi-
ovascular disease development and treatment, to the point where
major vendors are now seeking to deploy CFD solvers on their
medical imaging platforms. Detailed hemodynamic data availa-
ble from CFD generate large data sets due to complex flow,
which are difficult to render clearly – and thus communicate to
clinical stakeholders – using conventional engineering flow visu-
alization techniques. This is especially challenging considering
the four-dimensional nature of the flow patterns (i.e., rapidly
varying in space and time), as well as the clinical need for gener-
ating static reports rather than cumbersome digital animations.
Taking a cue from the rich history of biomedical illustration, our
goal is to use this opportunity for developing new data-driven
paradigms for visualizing blood flow based on the principles of
illustration, sequential art, and the visual vocabularies and con-
ventions of radiology and vascular surgery.
Keywords- flow visualization, computational fluid dynamics,
medical imaging, finite element methods, hemodynamics
I. INTRODUCTION
The forces to which blood and blood vessels are exposed
are widely believed to play a key role in the natural history
and clinical management of cardiovascular diseases. A varie-
ty of hemodynamic factors have, for example, been implicat-
ed in the development and progression of aneurysms and
atherosclerotic lesions, as well as their vulnerability to
thrombosis and/or rupture. Judicious control of hemodynam-
ic factors dictates the outcome of vascular interventions and
surgeries.
Although the putative links between hemodynamic forces
and vascular disease are now being elucidated down to the
level of genes, they have resisted translation to the clinic, a
fact attributable to the difficulty of measuring the hemody-
namic factors of interest, and hence of carrying out evidence-
based trials, in humans. This has led to the development and
now-widespread use of image-based CFD [1], whereby
computational fluid dynamics simulations are performed on
an individual’s artery geometry derived from clinical medi-
cal imaging. These simulations produce enormous amounts
of 4D data that must then be interpreted by biomedical engi-
neers and/or clinicians.
Visualizations of blood flow dynamics are invariably
presented to clinicians as “canned” animations, and tend to
rely on dense engineering representations that unselectively
portray both relevant and irrelevant details. This has tended
to discourage the use of hemodynamic information in the
clinic, and has likely fed a growing skepticism about the
clinical utility of CFD [2]. Building on past successes in vis-
ualizing blood flow using clinical visual paradigms [3], we
have turned to the idea “illustration-inspired” approaches to
essentially emphasizing the salient flow features; and to
develop the techniques needed to achieve this in a data-
driven way.
II. METHODS AND RESULTS
A. Aneurysms and Image-based CFD
Our first foray into illustrative flow visualization arises
from recent research demonstrating the potential for transi-
tional or turbulent flows in cerebral aneurysms, and its pos-
sible association with aneurysm rupture [6]. Briefly, an aneu-
rysm is a balloon-like defect of the blood vessel wall.
Roughly 5% of adults harbor aneurysms and because brain
scanning is performed more and more frequency, many un-
ruptured but potentially life-threatening aneurysms are being
discovered. The dilemma is that the annual risk of rupture is
low (~1%), often lower than the risk of treating the aneu-
rysm. Ideally, one would measure the aneurysm wall thick-
ness directly, but this is well beyond the resolution of even
the best medical imaging. Instead, it has been suggested that
complex blood flow dynamics may participate in the degra-
dation of the vessel wall, and thus provide important clues
about the rupture risk of an individual's aneurysm, and hence
the decision whether to risk treating it.
For the present investigations, geometries for the image-
based CFD models were derived from X-ray angiograms. As
detailed in [6], these geometries were discretized using dense
meshes, and the pulsatile blood flow dynamics were solved,
with very fine temporal resolutions, using the open-source
FEniCS finite element library, on a high-performance com-
puting cluster.
B. Illustration-inspired Visualization
Applying the insight of a communication scientist (with
deep knowledge of the power of emphasizing the essential)
2014 18th International Conference on Information Visualisation
1550-6037/14 $31.00 © 2014 IEEE
DOI 10.1109/IV.2014.19
333