P. Dourish and A. Friday (Eds.): Ubicomp 2006, LNCS 4206, pp. 35 – 51, 2006.
© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006
Historical Analysis:
Using the Past to Design the Future
Susan Wyche
1
, Phoebe Sengers
2
, and Rebecca E. Grinter
1
1
GVU Center
College of Computing
Georgia Institute of Technology
Atlanta, GA, USA
{spwyche, beki}@cc.gatech.edu
2
Information Science
Cornell University
Ithaca, NY, USA
sengers@cs.cornell.edu
Abstract. Ubicomp developers are increasingly borrowing from other
disciplines, such as anthropology and creative design, to inform their design
process. In this paper, we demonstrate that the discipline of history similarly has
much to offer ubicomp research. Specifically, we describe a historically-
grounded approach to designing ubicomp systems and applications for the home.
We present findings from a study examining aging and housework that
demonstrate how our approach can be useful to sensitize ubicomp developers to
the impact of cultural values on household technology, to reunderstand the home
space, and to spur development of new design spaces. Our findings suggest that
historically-grounded research approaches may be useful in more deeply
understanding and designing for context both in and outside of the home.
1 Introduction
As ubicomp moves beyond the work environment and into a broader social and
cultural world, researchers are drawing on an expanding set of disciplinary
perspectives to inform design. Ubicomp developers commonly employ anthropo-
logical methods, most notably ethnography [e.g., 24,26,27]. Similarly, researchers
borrow from art and design to develop novel ways to explore the home, such as
cultural probes [13]. In this paper, we describe how ubicomp developers can borrow
from another discipline useful for exploring domestic environments: history.
Examining the past has previously been used to inspire new form factors and styles
such as retro; we suggest that history can be further used to provide strategies that,
like anthropology, unpack the culture of the home and, like art-inspired design,
defamiliarize the home [2]. In this paper we present a study examining housework by
older adults and describe how we integrate historical analysis into the design process.
We then present findings from a study of older adults’ experiences with housework
that suggest history can be beneficial in understanding the culture of the home, in
defamiliarizing the home, and in spurring designers’ imaginations, thereby opening
new design spaces.