High-Speed Algorithm for Renewable Energy Based Microgrid
Fault Detection and Protective Coordination
Hashim A. Al Hassan
1
, Qiang Fu
2
, Vijay Bharavaju
2
, Yi Yang
2
, and Brandon M. Grainger
1
Electric Power Systems Laboratory – University of Pittsburgh Swanson School of Engineering; Pittsburgh, PA; USA
1
Eaton – Corporate Research and Technology, Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin; USA
2
haa20@pitt.edu / bmg10@pitt.edu
Abstract— The microgrid concept was proposed as a way to
facilitate the integration of distributed renewable energy
resources. However, due to the use of distributed energy
resources (DERs) microgrids face new protection challenges that
need resolved. One of those challenges is that traditional
protection methods, such as overcurrent protection, cannot be
used mainly because of low fault currents, bi-directionality of
power flow, and IEEE 1547 voltage ride-through requirements at
the point of common coupling (PCC). Therefore, fault current
and voltage magnitudes cannot be used as the protective
indicators as they may cause breaker misoperation or longer trip
times resulting in longer times to clear a fault. Additionally,
knowledge of the fault location is a necessary element to properly
protect the microgrid and avoid blinding or nuisance tripping.
Change in the phase difference between voltage and current is an
affective indicator that manifests on a short circuit in an islanded
microgrid with inverter-based DERs. This paper explores the
use of such an indicator and uses it as a foundation to propose a
novel high-speed fault detection and fault direction detection
method. A protective coordination algorithm is also proposed.
The performance of the proposed solution is demonstrated in the
PSCAD/EMTDC simulation environment.
Keywords— Distributed energy resources (DERs), fault
detection, fault location, microgrid, phase measurement, system
protection, voltage ride-through.
I. INTRODUCTION
Protection is one of the most critical and challenging
problems when it comes to microgrid systems especially when
the microgrid is islanded. This is due to the limited current
contribution from inverter-based sources, the bi-directionality
of power flow, and the different modes of operation that
require dynamic protection methods. Traditional over-current
protection is not a reliable method when it comes to protecting
the microgrid due to lower available source currents resulting
in longer trip times [1-2]. Most methods in the literature
depend on differential protection and a communication system
in order to achieve this objective which can be slow and costly
[1-3]. Relying on communication degrades the reliability
because the system becomes more prone to a single point of
failure. Others have used sequence components, which fails in
detecting balanced three-phase faults and is unreliable in the
case of unbalanced conditions [2], [4]. Some have used data
mining approaches along with the differentials which are
complex methods and also depend on communication [5]. The
same is true for traveling wave based approaches [6-7].
Wavelet analysis has been proposed in [8] and has not been
validated. In [9], the authors have added a flywheel in the
microgrid in order to boost up fault currents and use traditional
over-current protection. This method is costly and depends on
the availability of the flywheel. A combination of different
approaches have been proposed in [10] with differential
protection as the main strategy. This method is costly and slow
since it relies on other mechanisms as backup.
In this paper, an alternative scheme will be explored in
order to protect the microgrid. Specifically, the scheme will
overcome the issues of low fault levels and bi-directionality of
power flow that may cause blinding, nuisance tripping, or
longer tripping times. This alternative cannot be based on
voltage levels because renewables have to meet low-voltage
and high-voltage ride through requirements (IEEE 1547).
Detecting the relative fault location with respect to the
protective element is critical to deal with the bi-directionality
of power flow and to perform proper protection coordination.
If this objective is achieved along with detecting the fault with
good reliability and speed, microgrid protection becomes
manageable. The most practical method to achieve this is using
directional relays. However, traditional high-speed directional
relays depend on high fault currents and determine the
direction of current in 20 ms [11], which is not fast enough in
order to reliably protect the microgrid weak sources.
In this paper three main goals will be accomplished.
These include: One, to justify the use of phase change between
voltage and current as the main indictor to detect faults and
relative location (fault direction) to properly operate a circuit
breaker (CB). Two, utilize this indictor (phase change) and
develop an approach to identify the direction of the fault and
coordinate between circuit breakers faster than traditional high-
speed directional relays. In this case, phase detection will be
processed faster by exploiting all of the phase voltage of the
three phase system in both half-cycles. A method to extract the
fastest and the second fastest detection from the different
signals is also developed. Finally, the indicator is implemented
in a protective coordination algorithm.
II. PROPOSED FAULT DETECTION AND FAULT DIRECTION
DETECTION BASIC PRINCIPLE
A. System Configuration for Investigation
Correct modeling of the microgrid system under faults is
critical in our investigation in finding an indicator for fault
detection and relative location. The microgrid system that is
978-1-5090-2998-3/17/$31.00 ©2017 IEEE 519