Abstract Seventeen examples of a variant of ductal car-
cinoma in situ (DCIS) composed exclusively or predom-
inantly of spindle cells arranged in fascicles, whorls, and
solid sheets are described. The fascicular arrangement of
the spindle cells simulates the “streaming” phenomenon
associated with ordinary intraductal epithelial hyperpla-
sia (IDH). This process also resembles the myoid, solid
form of intraductal myoepithelial proliferation. The
women ranged in age from 38 years to 79 years with a
mean age of 59.3 years. Five patients presented with a
palpable mass. The remaining tumors were discovered
using mammography. The radiological appearances of
the lesions raised concern for carcinoma, but there were
no distinctive mammographic findings to suggest an un-
usual variant of DCIS. Cytological preparations were
suspicious for malignancy in two patients and were re-
ported as malignant in another case. Sixteen patients
were treated with wide local excision, and one woman
had a partial mastectomy. The tumors measured from
3 mm to 15 mm (mean 8.65 mm). In three cases, minute
foci of stromal invasion were associated with the
spindle cell DCIS. In another specimen, a 2.7-cm inva-
sive ductal carcinoma of no special type was identified
in an area away from the foci of the spindle cell DCIS.
None of the patients has experienced recurrence or me-
tastasis during the relatively short mean follow-up period
of 16.2 months (range 4–77 months). Spindle cell DCIS
is distinguished from the streaming pattern of ordinary
IDH by its solid growth pattern, lack of secondary spaces
or peripheral fenestrations, uniformity of appearance and
distribution of nuclei, cytological atypia in the range of
low to intermediate-grade DCIS, and negative immuno-
reaction with CK-34βE12 (HMW-CK903). When fenes-
trations are present, they are evident in areas of cribri-
form DCIS that merge with the solid, spindle cell areas
in hybrid ducts harboring both patterns. This admixture,
with conventional cribriform DCIS, and the association
with foci of invasive ductal carcinoma in some cases fur-
ther help recognition and confirmation of this lesion as
in situ carcinoma. When there is no transition from the
spindle cells to recognizable cribriform DCIS, distinc-
tion from intraductal myoepithelial hyperplasia (myoepi-
theliosis) requires immunostains for actin and S-100 pro-
tein. Recognition of this pattern of DCIS is important in
order to avoid its frequent misclassification as a benign
lesion.
Keywords Ductal carcinoma in situ · Spindle cell
DCIS · Intraductal breast cancer · Mammary ductal
intraepithelial neoplasia · Noninvasive breast cancer ·
Immunohistochemistry
Introduction
Intraductal proliferations in the breast seldom consist of a
pure population of spindled cells. Azzopardi [1] has re-
ferred to parallel orientation of neighboring cells in an in-
traductal proliferative process as “streaming” [1], and
Page and Anderson [7] consider the finding of swirling or
streaming as “strong, impelling evidence of benignancy”.
Most proliferations with partial spindling of cells fall
into the category of ductal hyperplasia. Myoepithelial
cells may also assume a myoid, spindle cell configura-
tion and proliferate in a solid fashion within multiple
ducts. This process has been named myoepitheliosis
[12]. Both intraductal epithelial hyperplasia (IDH) and
G. Farshid
Department of Pathology, Adelaide, South Australia
G. Farshid · D.J. Meredith
University of Adelaide, Division of Tissue Pathology,
Institute of Medical and Veterinary Science, Frome Road,
Adelaide, South Australia
S. Peiterse
Clinpath Laboratories, Kent town, South Australia
G. Farshid · S. Peiterse
Breastscreen SA, Wayville, South Australia
F. Moinfar · F.A. Tavassoli (
✉
)
Department of Gynecologic and Breast Pathology,
Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, Washington, D.C. 20306, USA
e-mail: tavassol@afip.osd.mil
Fax: +1-202-7823939
Virchows Arch (2001) 439:70–77
DOI 10.1007/s004280100446
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Gelareh Farshid · Farid Moinfar · David J. Meredith
Steve Peiterse · Fattaneh A. Tavassoli
Spindle cell ductal carcinoma in situ
An unusual variant of ductal intra-epithelial neoplasia that simulates
ductal hyperplasia or a myoepithelial proliferation
Received: 30 August 2000 / Accepted: 16 November 2000 / Published online: 11 May 2001
© Springer-Verlag 2001