Asian Studies Review. ISSN 1035-7823
Volume 22 Number 3 September 1998
© Asian Studies Association of Australia 1998. Published by Blackwell Publishers, 108 Cowley Road,
Oxford OX4 1JF, UK and 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148, USA.
FROM WALKMANS TO SMOG MASKS:
CONSUMPTION AND
OVER-CONSUMPTION IN ASIA
MORRIS LOW
Australian National University
While much has been made of the new rich of Asia, the current economic crisis
in parts of Asia has thrown into question how important culture and consump-
tion are in the formation of identity. This paper will explore the link between
material culture (as seen in the rise and decline of consumerism) and identity
formation in Asia. While what we call “Asia” consists of many diverse countries
and cultures, the rise of consumerism in many of them and the flow of goods
between them suggest that they share a number of common characteristics. A key
argument is that affluence is not necessarily empty, and that it provides a
community with new tools by which to define itself (Sennett 1996, 35). It is also
through consumption that individuals are able to fulfil their desire for multiple
social identities. While the mass media often refer to the enthusiasm for con-
sumption in Asia, the mechanisms which bring together these constructions
of the self have yet to be adequately identified. This asks the often neglected
question: consumption at what cost?
At a time when the Australian government is sending food aid to Indonesia,
questions of culture, consumption and identity seem to recede into the back-
ground. This paper is written in an attempt to explore what has been called,
at least in Korea, “sound consumption”, an attempt to work towards a socially-
responsible type of consumption which does not have a negative impact on the
lives of others. It will begin by exploring the linkages between consumption and
identity, and the rise and decline of consumerism in Asia, and will argue that
while there are divisions according to age group, gender and class, one can also
discern inter-generational identity groups based on fashion and taste. It con-
cludes with a discussion of the social costs of consumption and how materialistic
values affect the environment.