Jewish History (2012) 26: 5-15 © Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2012
DOI: 10.1007/s 10835-012-9154-6
Salome in the Middle Ages
WILLIAM CHESTER JORDAN
Princeton University, Princeton, USA
E-mail: wchester@princeton.edu
Abstract The chilling biblical story of Herodias' young daughter (known elsewhere by
name of Salome) and her role in the execution of John the Baptist has fascinated interpre
down the ages. This article explores medieval exegetical traditions with regard to the girl
the remarkable way her story was construed as pointing both to the horrific consequence
lust and anger and to the meta-narrative of the rise of the church, figured in Salome, the ho
of salvation.
The Gospel of Mark (6:17-29) and the Gospel of Matthew (14:3-12) re
the story of the beheading of John the Baptist. The narratives differ slightly
in the number and sorts of details they provide, but not in very significa
ways. Like medieval Christian exegetes who harmonized the Gospels, I h
blended the two accounts in the following paraphrase for the purpose of
article.
Herod the tetrarch ordered the arrest of John the Baptist and had
him imprisoned in chains. Herod's reason for doing so was the
furious complaint of his wife, Herodias, at John's public con
demnation of their marriage. Herodias was the former wife of
Philip, Herod's brother, whom she left to marry the tetrarch. John
railed against Herod, "It is against the law for you to marry your
brother's wife." At first Herod wanted to kill John, but he hesi
tated because of John's popularity and the widespread belief that
the Baptist was a prophet. Later Herod came to hold John in awe.
He did not understand all the Baptist's prophetic utterances, but
he enjoyed listening to him and came to regard him as a good and
upright man. Indeed, he protected him, letting him live despite his
wife's loathing and her continuing desire to have him killed.
An opportunity arose for her to fulfill her desire at Herod's birth
day banquet which his courtiers, military commanders, and vari
ous elite male members of society attended. Herodias's daughter
by her former husband danced before the assembled company, and
so delighted Herod that he swore to give her anything she wanted,
even half his realm. After talking to her mother, the girl asked for
John the Baptist's head on a dish. Herod's distress was palpable,