American Journal of Nursing Research, 2017, Vol. 5, No. 6, 226-234
Available online at http://pubs.sciepub.com/ajnr/5/65
©Science and Education Publishing
DOI:10.12691/ajnr-5-6-5
Are Psychiatric Nurses More Vulnerable to Domestic
Violence Compared with Nurses from Other Specialties?
Evon S. Shokre
1,*
, Nagwa A. Souilm
2
1
Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, Faculty of Nursing, Fayoum University, Egypt
2
Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, Faculty of Nursing, South Valley University, Egypt
*Corresponding author: evon.saber@yahoo.com
Abstract Women, especially working women, suffer from domestic or intimate partner violence worldwide.
Nurses are no exception. The study aim was to compare the magnitude of domestic violence and its effects among
psychiatry nurses compared with nurses from other specialties. This cross-sectional comparative study was
conducted on 120 psychiatric nurses from in Abbasiya Mental Hospital and 120 nurses in other specialties from
El-zaitoon hospital. Data were collected using a self-administered questionnaire with the HITS (Hurt, Insult,
Threaten, Scream) Scale for exposure to domestic violence, and the Women’s Experience with Battering (WEB)
scale to assess the meanings women attribute to their exposure to domestic violence. The fieldwork lasted from
April to June 2017. The nurses in the two groups had comparable demographic characteristics. More nurses in the
psychiatry group were not sharing in home expenses (p=0.01), had independent house (p<0.001), had their work
affecting home needs (p=0.03), and marital relations (p=0.04), and were asked to leave work by husband (p=0.03).
The psychiatry nurses had significantly lower mean and median HITS scores (p=0.007). More psychiatry nurses
reported thinking of leaving work as a consequence of domestic violence (p=0.001). In multivariate analysis, the
independent positive predictors of the HITS score were the nurse age at marriage, husband age, sharing in home
expenses, working overtime, and the work having a negative effect on marital life, while, the negative predictors
were being a psychiatric nurse, age, and living in an independent house. For the effects score, the independent
positive predictors were being a psychiatric nurse, having children, work having a negative effect on marital life,
in addition to the HITS score, whereas the negative predictors were the income and working for need. In
conclusion, the psychiatric nurses are less vulnerable to domestic violence, compared with other specialties;
however, the impact of this violence is more severe among them, with a higher tendency to leave the work for
this. The work environment, particularly in psychiatry should be improved with more flexible schedules and less
hours of overtime work. More intervention research is suggested to assess the effectiveness of various approaches
to deal with domestic violence.
Keywords: psychiatric nurses, domestic violence, intimate partner violence
Cite This Article: Evon S. Shokre, and Nagwa A. Souilm, “Are Psychiatric Nurses More Vulnerable to
Domestic Violence Compared with Nurses from Other Specialties?” American Journal of Nursing Research, vol.
5, no. 6 (2017): 226-234. doi: 10.12691/ajnr-5-6-5.
1. Introduction
Domestic or intimate partner violence is a universal
problem affecting women worldwide [1]. Statistics
estimate that 40% of women are abused by their husbands
or intimate partner [2]. However, the rates vary among
countries, with lower estimates in the Western world in
comparison to the east [3]. This has been attributed to
differences in cultural norms and values, where some
societies are more tolerable of such abuse under the
context that it is the right of the husband to punish his
wife [4,5]. Efforts have been exerted to decrease the rates
of domestic violence, but the outcomes are sub-optimal [6].
Research identified a number of factors significantly
influencing women’s exposure to domestic or intimate
partner violence. These include certain personal variables
such as the woman’s age, age at marriage and its length,
having children and their numbers and gender, and the
type of residence [7,8]. From these, it is deduced that
less educated women living at lower socioeconomic
levels are more vulnerable to such violence [9,10]. On the
other hand, highly educated women are less vulnerable to
domestic violence because they have skills and resources
to prevent violent behaviors [11]. Other factors are related
to husband. Thus, research showed that the perpetrator
husbands are more dominant and have more control over
their wives [12,13].
Working women seem to be more susceptible to
domestic violence [14] despite the assumption that
economically independent women might have feeling of
more security from such abuse [15]. Woman’s work can
lead to a poor-quality relationship with her husband, or
social undermining, which can enhance conflicts and
induce violence [16]. The problem is accentuated when