American Journal of Educational Research, 2017, Vol. 5, No. 4, 357-361
Available online at http://pubs.sciepub.com/education/5/4/3
©Science and Education Publishing
DOI:10.12691/education-5-4-3
A Needs Analysis for Poetry Appreciation Textbooks
in Universitites: An Exploratory Study
Oktaviani Windra Puspita
*
, Andayani, Herman J. Waluyo, Muhammad Rohmadi
Indonesian Language Education and Literature Department, Sebelas Maret University, Surakarta, Indonesia
*Corresponding author: okta89pwd@gmail.com
Abstract The objective of this study is to describe the needs for poetry appreciation textbooks in universities over
the years. To collect data, researchers used a qualitative descriptive method and an interview technique involving
university students and lecturers. The results of data analysis show that both university students and lecturers need
textbooks on the poetry appreciation. Within a needs analysis framework, lecturers had a clear mode of perceptions
of what they had been doing in terms of using poetry textbooks and talked about reasons why they focused on the
literary appreciation. The use of poetry appreciation textbooks in lectures they deliver can help university students
instill knowledge on the poetry appreciation through which they can pursue critical ideas, self-appreciation demands
and character education values. In-class literary events are also grounded in interactive practices in which university
students cooperate with each other in a range of lecturing activities: poetry reading, writing and discussing. This
pedagogy implies that educational needs for poetry appreciation contribute to classroom literary culture, provision of
poetry textbooks and university students’ engagement in poetry-related learning activities.
Keywords: needs analysis, textbooks, poetry appreciation, character education, self-appreciation
Cite This Article: Oktaviani Windra Puspita, Andayani, Herman J. Waluyo, and Muhammad Rohmadi,
“A Needs Analysis for Poetry Appreciation Textbooks in Universitites: An Exploratory Study.” American
Journal of Educational Research, vol. 5, no. 4 (2017): 357-361. doi: 10.12691/education-5-4-3.
1. Introduction
Poetry appreciation textbooks have widely been used in
universities as sources of information. Compiled by
different authors, the generic structure and sequence of
such textbooks may vary. Designed and used for the sake
of literary learning or study of certain objects of knowledge
and arts, poetry appreciation texbooks primarily contain
the presentation of scientific principles, literary criticism
[5] and assessment of poems. In a general term, a poetry
appreciation is a result of critical thinking, and a quest for
poetry intrinsic values in which systematic understading
and interpretion are built to express literary messages to
the world. Through appreciation activities, literary
criticism is expected to arise in the readers’ minds, and
most of all, in the world of poetry, alternative options to
deal with the problems of real life [8] are worth
considering. Therefore, poetry appreciation constitutes an
integral part of movement through which poetry textbooks
significantly require adequate attention in all contexts of
literary theories [5] and practices.
In many ways, however, there is an urgent demand to
undertake a needs analysis for poetry appreciation
textbooks because its contribution to conceptualize poetry
as self-discovery, performance and self-criticism needs to
evaluate. In addition, poetry is a window of exploration in
which an in-depth study commonly called an exploratory
study can be done accordingly. An exploratory study is an
initial stage of research and development to determine
whether or not lecturers and university students are in
need of poetry appreciation textbooks. That is why this
study provides a great deal of insights into interviews with
lecturers and university students to elicit related
information on the use of poetry appreciation books in
learning and teaching activities. Instead, on one end is a
view of learning to explore core values behind every poem,
popularly known as character education values in the 2013
Indonesian curriculum, and as a continuation of an
exploratory study, students’ engagement in this poetry
exploration should relate to quality instructional practices.
In that sense, poetry appreciation textbooks in both
private and public universities are exteremly needed, so
that all lecturers and students use the textbooks to prepare
for learning and teaching processes in class. As primary
learning resources, poetry textbooks are crucial for
lecturers and students across domains, and this view leads
to the development of curriculum and pedagogy by
providing a needs analysis to diagnose textbooks-related
problems. Therefore, this article explores the ways in
which poetry appreciation textbooks in universities are
assessed within a needs analysis perspective involving
lecturers and students. It also sets out to describe how
poetry appreciation textbooks meet the needs of lecturers
and students at Indonesian Language Education and
Literature Departments of private and public universities
in Central Java and Special Region of Yogyakarta,
Indonesia. The benefits of this research are (1) to enrich
the science and (2) to develop theories of poetry
appreciation addressed in poetry textbooks for either
lecturers or students in such universities.