International Relations
1–21
© The Author(s) 2014
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0047117814562219
ire.sagepub.com
Security and citizenship in
the global South: In/securing
citizens in early republican
Turkey (1923–1946)
Pinar Bilgin and Basak Ince
Bilkent University
Abstract
The relationship between security and citizenship is more complex than media portrayals based
on binary oppositions seem to suggest (included/excluded, security/insecurity), or mainstream
approaches to International Relations (IR) and security seem to acknowledge. This is particularly
the case in the post-imperial and/or postcolonial contexts of global South where the transition
of people from subjecthood to citizenship is better understood as a process of in/securing. For,
people were secured domestically as they became citizens with access to a regime of rights and
duties. People were also secured internationally as citizens of newly independent ‘nation-states’
who were protected against interventions and/or ‘indirect rule’ by the (European) International
Society, whose practices were often justified on grounds of the former’s ‘failings’ in meeting the
so-called ‘standards of civilization’. Yet, people were also rendered insecure as they sought to
approximate and/or resist the citizen imaginaries of the newly established ‘nation-states’. The
article illustrates this argument by looking at the case of Turkey in the early Republican era
(1923–1946).
Keywords
citizenship, global South, International Society, security, standards of civilization, Turkey
Introduction
The relationship between security and citizenship is more complex than media portrayals
based on binary oppositions seem to suggest (included/excluded, security/insecurity),
or mainstream approaches to International Relations (IR) and security seem to acknowl-
edge (insecurity originates from outside the state boundaries, and states provide security
Corresponding author:
Pinar Bilgin, Bilkent University, 6800 Ankara, Turkey.
Email: pbilgin@bilkent.edu.tr
562219IRE 0 0 10.1177/0047117814562219International RelationsBilgin and Ince
research-article 2014
Article
by guest on December 20, 2014 ire.sagepub.com Downloaded from