©
Experimental and Numerical Analysis of Shorted
Interlaminations in Transformer Cores
Ivan A. Hernandez-Robles
Departamento de
Electronica y Control
Centro de Tecnología Avanzada,
CONACYT-CIATEQ A.C.
San Luis Potosi, Mexico
ivan.hernandez@ciateq.mx
Juan C. Olivares-Galvan, Irvin
Lopez-Garcia, J. Luis Hernandez-
Avila, R. Escarela-Perez,
Departamento de Energia
Universidad Autonoma
Metropolitana, Mexico D.F.
jolivares@correo.azc.uam.mx
Salvador Magdaleno-Adame
Magnetic Engineering Department
Correlated Magnetics Research
Huntsville, AL, USA
transformer.consultant@gmail.com
Abstract— This paper presents an experimental and
numerical analysis regarding shorted electrical steel laminations
of core of a small transformer core (120 VA single-phase shell-
type transformer). Experimental tests were performed to
measure the core losses of the transformer with and without
shorted electrical steel laminations. Soft solder was utilized to
produce the shorted region in the transformer core.
Furthermore, 3-D Finite Element (FE) simulations were carried
out to compute the eddy current losses in the core of transformer
with shorted electrical steel laminations. The laminations of the
core and their insulation were taken into account in the
transformer model. Finally, several FE simulations were
performed to calculate the eddy current losses for several cases,
where the location and size of the shorted lamination region was
varied in the core of transformer.
Keywords—core loss; eddy current loss; electrical steel; finite
element; interlamination; insulation; no load test; steady state
I. INTRODUCTION
The importance to quantify the effects of shorted
interlaminations have increased since transformer
manufactures want to reduce core fault losses, avoid scrap and
thereby economic losses; the analysis and results obtained in
this paper intended be a support tool for the engineers in charge
in solving this issue. Shorted laminations are a critic problem
in power transformers that can eventually escalate into
catastrophic faults and probably result in an overall network
failure.
The name "electrical steel" refers to special steel grade, it has
good magnetic properties such as magnetization curve,
permeability, coercive field, and core losses (W/kg). These
materials are typically used to manufacture inductors, reactors,
electric motors, and transformers. Basically, these steels are
alloys of Fe-Si and they are laminated materials having a
thickness of less than 0.5 mm. For transformers usually the
thickness is in the range of 0.18 to 0.27 mm [1]. There are
many factors that are considered as possible causes of increase
of core losses: i) Improper handling of the core steel during
transformer manufacturing (see Fig. 1(a)); ii) Poor insulation
coating of lamination layers (see Fig. 1(b)); iii) Improper
arrangements of air gap regions (see Fig. 2); iv) Burrs forming
at slit edges or at the cut joints; v) Geometry of core pile during
annealing for a batch-type furnace [2]; vi) Thermal cycle of
core annealing not fulfilled, for example annealing time is
incomplete [3]; vii) Atmosphere inside of the furnace during
the annealing process; viii) Length of the air gaps [4]; ix)
Dimensions of the core, especially the thickness; x) Number of
electrical laminations per layer [5]; xi) When the carbon steel
clamping frames make contact with the edges of the steel
laminations of transformer core (see Fig. 3). Factors i), ii), iv),
vi) and xi) can often produce shorted laminations.
a)
b)
Fig. 1. Factors that increase core losses in the transformer. a) Mechanical stress
is produced in laminations in the process involving a radius that is too small
and sharp corners; b) The insulation coating of the laminations is damaged
when there is an incorrect handling of the core steel during manufacturing.
Burrs on individual steel laminations caused by poor cutting
processes can create electrical connections between adjacent
2016 IEEE PES Transmission & Distribution Conference and Exposition - Latin America (PES T&D-LA). Morelia, Mexico
978-1-5090-2875-7/16/$31.00 ©2016 IEEE