26
Harvard Educational Review Vol. 88 No. 1 Spring 2018
Copyright © by the President and Fellows of Harvard College
Ethics, Identity, and Political Vision:
Toward a Justice-Centered Approach to
Equity in Computer Science Education
SEPEHR VAKIL
University of Texas at Austin
In this essay, Sepehr Vakil argues that a more serious engagement with critical tra-
ditions in education research is necessary to achieve a justice-centered approach to
equity in computer science (CS) education. With CS rapidly emerging as a distinct
feature of K–12 public education in the United States, calls to expand CS education
are often linked to equity and diversity concerns around expanding access to girls and
historically underrepresented students of color. Yet, unlike other critical traditions in
education research, equity-oriented CS research has largely failed to interrogate the
sociopolitical context of CS education. To move toward a justice-centered approach to
equity, Vakil argues, we must simultaneously attend to at least three features of CS
education: the content of curriculum, the design of learning environments, and the
politics and purposes of CS education reform. While there are many avenues of criti-
cal inquiry within and across each of these topics, the focus in this essay is on the role
of ethics in the curriculum, the role of identity in CS learning environments, and the
significance of a clear political vision for CS education.
Keywords: computer science education, critical theory, STEM education, ethics,
sociocultural theory
No one wants to hear why you are behind. Run faster, jump higher . . . We are
here to talk about new possibilities for you, next door . . . Next door to you is the
largest, most robust industry in the whole world called Silicon Valley. And some-
how, someway, it has passed over you . . . So buckle down and get on up! And
make it happen! . . . [Prep] will be a resource for Silicon Valley! . . . If I learn
computer science . . . I can see the goal! The goal is Google! The goal is Face-
book! The goal is Microsoft! (Vakil, 2016)