X-RAY SPECTROMETRY, VOL. 26, 2"9-256 (1997)
Application of XRF and Correspondence Analysis
to Provenance Studies of Coastal and Inland
Archaeological Pottery from the Mngeni River
Area, South Africa
C. Punyadeera,1 A. E. Pillay,1* L. Jacobson
2
and G. Whitelaw3
I Department of Chemistry, University of the Witwatersrand, P.O. Wits 2050, South Ajrica
2 McGregor Museum, P.O. Box 316, Kimberley 8300, South Mrica
3 Natal Museum, Private Bag 9070, Pietermaritzburg 3200, South Mrica
XRF spectrometry was applied to provenance studies of Iron Age pottery specimens that originated from the
Mngeni river area in South Africa. Ten transition metals (Se to Zn) were determined in 107 potsherds, excavated
from four different sites. The data were subjected to a computerized mathematical technique (correspondence
analysis), which was used to group the samples according to the similarity of their elemental distributions. The
groupings were interpreted in terms of social or cultural interaction between the sites. © 1997 by John Wiley &
Sons, Ltd.
X-Ray Spectrom. 26, 249-256 (1997) No. of Figures : 5 No. of Tables: 3 No. of References : 16
INTRODUCTION
Studies of Iron Age archaeolO§ical sites in the Kwazulu/
Natal province of South Africa have generally focused
on developing a cultural typology based on ceramic
style and establishing its chronology and spatial dis-
tribution. However, the communities which produced
these wares did not live in isolation from each other:
South Africa. The aim was to provenance the sherds so
that any links between coastal and inland sites could be
established.
EXPERIMENTAL
Sample coUection
trade and social exchange contacts would have existed Samples were excavated from the four sites by standard
but data on this are not always obvious from a simple archaeological methods. Sherds selected for analysis
typological analysis of pottery. . were plain non-decorated specimens and 107 specimens
Provenance studies provide a more objective assess- 4 were selected for investigation. Figure 1 is a map illus-
ment of the movement of pottery as each vessel carries a trating the excavation areas and approximate points of
chemical 'fingerprint' derived from the clay from which sampling.
it was made. It thus becomes a simple matter to estab- Sherds from four sites were used for the analysis.
lish chemical compositional groups, using a suitable Three sites, Mzonjani,4 Nanda
5
and KwaGandaganda,6
multivariate statistical procedure, in order to detect out- were occupied at different times (the 3rd, 7th and
liers or overlapping samples which could indicate mid-8th centuries AD, respectively) whilst the fourth
imports or exports. site, Emberton Way,? was occupied over the full time
Modern analytical techniques were first applied to period, albeit probably sporadically. Table 1 illustrates
the study of provenancing in 1957,
1
and since then a the phases present at each site together with their
number of analytical techniques such as neutron activa- symbols as used in the correspondence analysis plots
tion analysis (NAA), particle-induced x-ray emission below. Of special interest is the fact that Horwitz et al.?
(PIXE), inductively coupled plasma (ICP) and x-ray
fluorescence (XRF) have been developed which provide
, routine and accurate analyses. In this study, data were
• " obtained by using XRF spectroscopy. XRF has proved
. to be a useful tool in archaeology for determining the
elemental composition of a variety of materials such as
pottery, clays, hornfels and cave and open-site sedi-
ments.
2
•
3
In this investigation, XRF was applied to pot-
sherds from four sites in the KwazulujNatal province,
• Correspondence to: A. E. Pillay.
CCC 0049- 8246/97/050249- 08 $17.50
© 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Table 1. Dating of the sherd samples from the four sites
Site
Mzonjani
Nanda
KwaGandaganda
Emberton Way
Emberton Way
Emberton Way
Emberton Way
Phase Date (AD) Svmbol
Matola 4th C m
Msuluzi 7th C n
Mdondondwane 8th C k
Matola 4th C eM
Msuluzi 7th C eN
Ntshekane 9th C e
Ndondondwane 8th C eK
Received 15 November 1995
Accepted 4 October 1996