Sisir’s Tears: Bhakti and Belonging in Colonial Bengal
Varuni Bhatia
Published online: 29 March 2017
© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2017
Abstract This article explores the manner in which bhakti emerges as a politi-
cotheological concept in the period of rising nationalism in colonial Bengal. It
examines Śrī Amiya Nimāī Carita, a multivolume sacred biography of Kr
˙
s
˙
n
˙
a-Cai-
tanya (1486–1533) authored by Sisir Kumar Ghosh (1840–1911) between 1885 and
1910. Ghosh was a journalist and a publisher with a reputation for anticolonialism
and Hindu revivalism. Ghosh’s autobiographical and didactic prefaces attached to
this sacred biography allow us to parse out a complex narrative of filial bonds and
belonging that is integrally connected to an ambrosial (amiya) Nima ¯ı ¯ (Caitanya’s
nickname) and the devotional collective dedicated to him. Furthermore, these sacred
biographies draw correspondences between the figure of Nima ¯ı ¯ himself and the idea
of Bengal—its history, culture, people, and society. This article systematically
examines the evidence provided in this sacred biography of such overlaps between
the figure of Caitanya and love for Bengal to argue that in the years leading up to the
Swadeshi movement (1905–8), Vais
˙
n
˙
ava bhakti, with its emphasis on love, loss, and
femininity, arises as the idiom of comprehending and reifying ideas of intimacy and
belonging to one’s homeland. In this fashion, they intellectually prepare the ground
for the emergence of the powerful notion of deś-bhakti in its modern form—as
patriotic nationalism based upon love and devotion for homeland.
Keywords Bhakti · anticolonial nationalism · Bengal · Vais
˙
n
˙
avism · Caitanya
(1486–1533) · Sisir Kumar Ghosh (1840–1911) · Śrī Amiya Nimāī Carita · Swadeshi
movement · deś-bhakti
In the last decade of the nineteenth century, a multivolume sacred biography of
Kr
˙
s
˙
n
˙
a Caitanya (1486–1533), a devotee of Kr
˙
s
˙
n
˙
a, caught the imagination of the
& Varuni Bhatia
varunib@umich.edu
Department of Asian Languages and Cultures, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
123
International Journal of Hindu Studies (2017) 21:1–24
DOI 10.1007/s11407-017-9205-1